|_|_|_| ULTIMATE SIG TOURNAMENT |_|_|_| VOTE NOW!!

[classicfan]

First one to 5 votes moves on to the next round:

Classic_Fan (1)

VS.

Shuya Nanahara (3)

SAWF'er (2)

VS.

Snitch (2)

[0s0a0b0u]

i think the SAWF'er is the best beacuse they have their proper logos which makes it more authentic, and it's more like a war than the other cuz the other one look like fueds but there all great here it the way i judge them
1.SAWF'er
2.snitch
3.Classic_fan
4.shuya nanahara

[Chris182]

I like the sig that SAWF'er did the best....it shows more that it is TNA vs WWE....and it has the real logos....i just think it is the best one there.

[Cass]

i thought we were getting more time???

[classicfan]

we were but i got tired of waiting...

[Deleted]

Sawf

[Epic]

classicfan said:

we were but i got tired of waiting...

So professional

ANYWAY, graphically, I think Snitch has the best work. I would've been a bit happier if you didn't laze out and switched the "RAW" logo with a TNA one, but it's all good!

Here would be my "ranking"



1. Snitch - See above
See also; get that ing stroke off Angle and Cena!

2. Shuya - I'm not liking the uneven border. If you wanted that look, then you have to make it APPARENT that you're going for the messy look. The border just looks odd with the top one being okay and the bottom not actually reaching the bottom. I also would've liked to see real logos used, despite your text work being good here. Your blending looks the best out of anyone else's here, and you used the space provided better than anyone, aside from Snitch. The blending on Angle and Batista looks a little rough, but still, not bad.

3. SAWfer - A bit cluttered, but the size requirements were horrid, so you're forgiven. I think all of the pictures you've chosen work well, and the is pretty good sans the white vertical blur over Joe. It breaks up the color a bit and looks poor. Would've liked a border. Overall, nice for what you were given.

4. Classic - It seems like your background is very plain, which is good for a type of graphic like this, but the overall appearance comes off very sloppy. I'm guessing you made your own cuts for this, and if you didn't, then you unneccessarily applied a stroke to PSDs. The quality of the images isn't very good, and the jaggy edges don't help. Like Shuya, I would have liked to seen real logos and a not so sloppy border. The background pictures, HHH and Angle, are well chosen and well placed, but are killed with the OD shadows/glows/spray paint. Especially since you defined the whole graphic as red, and put a blue one on HHH. I could see this if Edge had blue in him, or if his side of the bg did, but right now, it just sticks out in a not good way.

So those are my votes.
This was my unfinished proto that I stopped when I saw the sizes were changed less than a day before entries were due. The logos were place holders:


So yeah, Shuya and Snitch got my vote.

[Kody]

Sawf



A lot cleaner, and a better theme. Nice pic choices.

[classicfan]

u guys have to vote for two...one in each match

[becca]

In the first match:
Shuya (my choice): The colors, blending and effects give it a really cohesive look that is easy to look and and process. By simplifying the colors to blue and red, it is easy to discern the two sides. I don't mind that you didn't use the real logos

Classic: First, I don't like the border, but thats besides the point. I like the layout, with the action shots in the center, but the quality of the images sucks. The text is pretty cool but the placement is very unoriginal.

In the second match:
SAWF'er: There is a lot going on in this and I wish you would have done something to really make a point of emphasis. The layout is nice, with the face offs, but it just seems cluttered. The logos don't really fit there to me, plus the TNA one is pretty bad quality which is distracting. A border would have been nice too.

Snitch (my choice): I like the logos in the background, and the quality is good, but the whole smackdown vs raw thing is a bit distracting once you realize what it is. I think you could have chosen better pictures too, but they look clean. I don't know if the stroke was necessary. I like that you didn't try to do too much.

[Snitch]

Shuya for the first one.

Best of luck Sawf mate.

[Ryan]

Shuya Nanahara & Snitch. They look more professional than the other 2.

[classicfan]

Keep it up guys!

[tylerblackohyes]

I vote Snitch - it just overall looks better than SAWF'er's and uses the size restrictions well.

I really don't think anyone else is going to vote, so how about we say Snitch and I win for our consecutive matches?

[classicfan]

^ ok