No polls or bad replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following:
1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?)
2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. However you need to compare with the other animations in the match. Put thought into your votes, don't just say who you are voting and leave a sentence, put some effort in.
3) Forum status must be above Jobber
If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.
Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10, but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.
If a title match ends in a draw, the champion retains.
Post by wwextreme25 on Jan 26, 2014 17:25:34 GMT -5
nice turnout, glad to see it!!
Ace: again like your last match i voted on, you were missing a few pics from the animation which caused it to not have a good flow to it and looked choppy. I liked the joint movement in places though, i.e the way he moved the chair around the back of him etc, i just think you need to work on taking more pics for fluidity. 4.5/10
Jamie: Nice bend off the top rope for momentum, couldve done with one or two more frames but wasnt too noticeable. The jump off the top rope lacked frames a lot though. I think it needed a lot more joint movements and pics to be taken in order to get the full effect. It jumped way too quick and looked very strange to me wasnt that fluid. Also i didnt like how sabu had such a dead reaction but the table break was a good effort. 4/10
ZMW: very nice man. Loved the taunt at the beginning, and the way punk put the chair behind him - wouldve loved to see that part done in mid air though to look more like the original version but not a major problem. Also, it looks better with this move done off te top rope bu again, not a big deal just a personal preference of mine.Easily the smoothest animation of the 3, decent joint movements in punks legs wouldve love to have seen more of a reaction but it was still fine. The tape kinda bugged me a little but all in all, you definitely had the best animation imo. 5.5/10
Vote: ZMW..although he didnt have the best setup etc, he did have the best animation and smoothest of the 3.
Animation Profile: 1x World Heavyweight Champion
2x High Flyers Champion (Longest Reigning)
1x Entrance King Champion (Longest Reigning)
3x Slammy Award Winner
1x Money in the bank winner
Post by Scottanized on Jan 26, 2014 17:31:51 GMT -5
Jamie: JS, the fact that sign says "One Night Only" Really annoys me considering everyone is using names like that now adays. The move was pretty smooth. Dykstra was pretty fidgety during the impact and had a delayed reaction. Felt he sohuld have sold how it affected his back, not kicking his legs. Sabu also stopped moving. Ace: It had smooth parts but at the same time felt kind of fidgety. Miz was stiff and had no reaction. The jump from Punk was alright but he needed way more pics, was kind of stiff, and had strange movements, such as the fact he went forward then back. No reaction kills it. ZMW: Easily the best. Very smooth. Realistic movements by both. Loved the jump and the way punk put the chair behind him. The reaction was short but so much better than the other two. String was seen though. Vote: Easily ZMW, his animation outshined the others.
Post by /X Metal Sorenges x "Mac Oh J~ on Jan 26, 2014 17:44:19 GMT -5
My vote goes to ZWM.
Jamie: I really like the set up for the Arabian Facebuster imo. Perhaps it would have been been better if you had Sabu take a slight squat before the initial jump, since it seemed a bit dry. In mid air it was smooth for a couple frames but going down toward the table for impact, it got a bit choppy although the movements from Sabu were ok but they could use a bit of improvement. The impact was good but Sabu came down very awkwardly and could have used alot more pictures and Kenny was fidgety and changed direction midway through. 6.8/10
Ace: At the beginning the taunt from CM Punk was very fast and could have used alot of pictures throughout the animation. The joint movement however seemed to be pretty standard but the lack of frames really detracted the quality of the animation unfortunately. Before impact, it would have suited the ani a bit more if you bent CM Punk's knees a bit more to make it flow a little bit more. I didn't really like how inactive the Miz was on the table, it didn't really help the realism factor of the animation so much. The table break was good but the reactions from both looked choppy as well. 6.6/10
ZMW: Very nice animation you have here ZWM. The set-up up wasn't the best but the animation really disregards that notion. The movements were CM Punk puts the chair behind his back seemed a little to drawn out and slow imo. The jump from the steel step looked really smooth, it flowed very well although CM Punk looked a bit stiff in his knees and the spacing was a little bit off but it isn't to much of a dilemma. Another note that I observed was Christian's movements on the ladder weren't very fluent and consistent but the impact and reaction from Christian was quite good. 7.2/10
Post by [The Ukrainian One] Dimburuk on Jan 27, 2014 7:41:10 GMT -5
Jamie : nice ani, needs more frames, especially when Sabu squats, the movements in air were choppy, Sabu moved with big gaps in air, the impact wasn't very good, looked very choppy and movements weren't great, table break could've been better, reaction of Sabu is kinda weird.
Ace : i like how Punk holds the chair at the begininng, but the animation needs more frames, ani was made in 12 mins, should've took more time to make it, mid air was choppy and because of that movements don't look good, table break was better than Jamie's IMO but still it looked very weird, also some blurry pics.
ZMW : nice one, i like the taunt and that you even moved Christian a bit, animation was the smoothest out of those three and had the best flow, taunt at the beginning was nice as movements were good, i don't like how Punk got the chair under his ass before jumping, i also saw some tape, but it wasn't too noticable, mid-air flow was good and had okay movements, reaction was also better than Jamie's and Ace's, but would be better if it was a bit longer. Nice job.
Vote : ZMW, for having a smoother animation and better movements.
Animation achievements :
1. First ever Intercontinental Champion in history
2. Beginners champion[2x]
3. Hosted a PPV
Jamie : Nice arena, I really like it. Also, great lighting. Into the ani - Sabu should have had a little 'squat' before the jump. The ani lacked pictures which made it look choppy. The table was fidgety too. Otherwise, reaction was alright. Not much to say really, don't rush yourself next time.
Ace : Pretty smooth ani. I like how you had Punk taunt with the chair and squat before jumping. Air time lacked a few pictures which made it look rushed. The table break was nice, and the impact was correct. Lacked a bit of reaction though.
ZMW : The taunts before the jump were fidgety, but Christian moving before the impact was a nice touch. Ani didn't seem to lack pictures and it was smooth. I would've just edited the speed a little bit. You had the best reaction out of the three, and it kinda made your ani so well done.
Vote goes to ZMW, has less flaws and smoother ani.