SUMMER CATASTROPHE III: Match 2

[Deleted]

Am I the only one who gets asked by noobs where I get my tables?



Hardcore Championship:

Andeh(c) vs Anyone who enters
Stip: Any move through stacked tables

Andeh:


Showoff:


Nico:
minus.com/lpndmLNhLcLr8 (CLICK LINK)

Jack:




How to vote on matches:

1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?)

2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended)

If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.

Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.


VOTING ENDS IN 48 HOURS

[Deleted]

Andeh: Great ani here. Had an excellent flow, excellent airtime, and pretty much no fidgetyness at all. Only issues I saw were Kash being stiff in the fireman's carry, and Kash not having much of a reaction (although people usually have dead reactions after going through tables).

Showoff: Good job here. It was smooth and not that stiff. My main problem with this is that Christian was fidgety in mid air after he left the ladder and right before he hit the first table. I also didn't like how late he turned to his side when he was falling.

Nico: Okay ani here. It looks like you had enough pictures, I just think you set the speed too high. The table break was too fast and too fidgety for my liking. Also Morrison's legs should have bent more before he jumped.

Jack: Good ani here. It was smooth and not that fidgety. I had a couple problems with it though. First is that there was no reaction at all from either men after the DDT or even a rope bounce. Also when Gabriel springboarded, the rope should have gone down with him as he bent his legs.

Vote: Andeh
His animation overall had the least amount of major flaws, good effort by everyone here.

[ace]

Andeh: I'm impressed with this animation, the reason being is that you animated with those figures pretty well, which I think would be pretty hard to do considering how it has limited joints and all that, but it was choppy in the reaction but it still flowed pretty well throughout the rest, good job.

Showoff: Pretty good job, IMO the smoothest out of the animations and the best camera angle but seemed a bit too easy to make, I get you were trying to do a bullhammer but to me it looked more like a punch. And a punch is way to weak to have a guy fall from a ladder like that which makes it seem unrealistic. but all in all it was good.

Nico: It's decent, I get its a hard move but I would recommend watching a video of a wrestler doing the move so you can get the right movements. It just seemed way too fast and choppy. Good effort though.

Jack: Good job. I like the smoothness in the spring board and mid-air but after that it all goes downhill, The string was pretty noticeable, and was a little too slow during the table break. It would've also been better if you had added more of a reaction and a rope bounce.

Vote: Andeh

[/X Metal Sorenges x "Mac Oh J~]

My vote goes to Andeh on this one.

Nico: At the beginning I like the taunt coming from John Morrison, but I feel like it was very fast and choppy. The squat before the double moonsault wasn't bad, but Morrison could have went a little deeper into the squat to make it flow a little bit better. The double moonsault itself was very floaty and choppy, I noticed in mid air that you moved the stacked table that Bourne was laying on which didn't benefit the ani at all. The impact was very nicely done and the reaction was good but it was a little bit to fast for preference. 7.6/10

Jack: At the beginning I really like the squat coming from Justin Gabriel, the springboard itself was very smooth and the joint movement was pretty good for the most part. I thought that Gabriel could have had a larger squat before the jump into the DDT, the jump into the DDT wasn't bad at all but Gabriel looked a little stiff in mid air, something looked a little odd about the table break which I wasn't to fond of, it would have been nice to see a final reaction at the end. 8.2/10

#Showoff: Really good animation you have here Showoff. The punch from Wade Barret flowed well and it was very smooth, the joint movement was excellent. I like the fall from Christian but it looked a bit fidgety before Christian fell through the tables but it wasn't very noticeable. The table break was perfect imo, the impact couldn't have been done better but the lack of reaction was disheartening. 8.4/10

Andeh: This was a good animation you have here Andeh. The transition into the F5 was very nicely done, for a RA Lesnar the turn was pretty good and the throw into the F5 itself had great air time and it had good amount of flow as well. Kid Kash was a little stiff in his legs but the impact through the table was very nicely done but when Kid Kash spun onto his back, it just looked a bit fast and choppy for some reason. 8.5/10

[Deleted]

Andeh: Really nicely done, had a good flow through-out with a nice amount of pictures, for Kash, I felt the joint movement was a bit lacking in the mid-air part but besides that I liked that aspect, Brocks movement too was really nice, y'know, a lot of people do move the joints but not to the right degree, I think Brock hit the mark for it, the reaction was sorta lacking, I would've liked Kash to have held his chest or something like that, the lighting was alright and I only saw one or two strings, overall a really nice animation.

7/10

Showoff: Nice work, the animation had a great flow through-out, I felt as though Barrett moved a tiny bit too much, not like choppy but kind of exaggerated, maybe not as big left arm movements would've been better, anyway, that was not a big problem, Christian however was lacking in mid-air movement, he kind of moved then stopped then started again with sporadic movements, anyway, the reaction just like Andeh was lacking, the lighting was good and I only saw one shadow.

7/10

Nico: Nice to see you back on here, the animation was probably one of your best, the animation had a pretty nice flow but Jomo seemed to jump up once at the second flip, the joint movement was alright, it seemed awkward but at least it was visible, I would've liked a bit more movement from Bourne too sitting on the tables, the reaction was nice but wasn't overly fitting to the move, still you added a real reaction unlike others, the lighting was nice and I only saw a few bits of string, nicely done man, keep at it.

4.5/10

Jack: Lol, saw string, animation was pretty smooth through-out but very fidgety during the table break, the joints were barely moved through-out, Gabe moved at the start then it stopped, saw string, the reaction was completely non-existent, at least Andeh and Showoff had the guys reacting move, saw string, lighting was good, that's all I can say.

1.5/10

This was a really hard choice, but I'm going to vote Andeh purely because he had a harder move, sorry Showoff.

Vote: Andeh

[Scotty]

Andeh...*films* : Amazing job here mate. Incredibly smooth. Brock was pretty smooth although I would have liked if he had a little more movements after hitting the F5 like appeared to almost fall or bend down more. Kash's fall was smooth, but he appeared a little slidy.

Showoff: Wade had a smooth punch that wasn't that stiff, but I would have liked to have seen him do a little more after the move. Christian's reaction to the punch was nice, but he should have spun when he fell, it looked strange the way he turned mid air.

Nico: Nice taunt, but the move was really fidgety and stiff.

Jack: Pretty smooth. Gabriel had nice movements and wasn't stiff until the actual DDT. The River was really stiff though and his joints were barely moved in the entire animation. Would have been nice if atleast Gabriel moved after the move too.

Vote: Andeh, overall the best animation