|
Post by "Living Legend" Duttanized on Apr 20, 2013 16:03:17 GMT -5
"Luke, I am your father..." Teacher vs Student: Angus vs Rob -Stip: Chaos Theory Angus: img339.imageshack.us/img339/8597/304rob.gifRob: How to vote on matches: No polls and no suckish replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following: 1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?) 2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended) If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions. Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match. VOTING ENDS IN 48 HOURS
|
|
|
Post by wwextreme25 on Apr 20, 2013 16:09:24 GMT -5
incredible job man. Good luck.
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: May 14, 2024 21:02:21 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 20, 2013 16:49:35 GMT -5
ANGUS: Great animation man, the animation was smooth through-out but I felt it missed a few pictures in the reaction of the shining wizard, both figures were moved very well through-out, if I had to nitpick the only problem about joint movement is Bourne during preperation for the kick, the reactions were really good, the first one had a good bounce and the second one showed a perfect dead reaction, I saw several shadows through-out, but no string, great work Angus. 9/10 ROB: Good animation here, the animation was very smooth, the figures were moved fairly well through-out the animation, Sin Cara was a bit stiff during the rolling and CM Punk was a bit stiff when waiting for Sin Cara to bounce, you moved the joints fine but the movement wasn't great, CM Punk needed more of a reaction after the kick, he just turned around and flailed his arms around, I saw no strings but did see a few shadows, not bad Rob, but I've seen better from you. 8/10
Vote: ANGUS
|
|
SuperBradOPig
Main Eventer
Hello there.
Joined on: Nov 23, 2012 18:12:22 GMT -5
Posts: 1,102
|
Post by SuperBradOPig on Apr 20, 2013 17:06:35 GMT -5
Sheesh! What a match! I love the stip! Angus: Nice one. I liked the way you added extra moves which means extra time but than can be a bad idea. It can lead to rushing. Then a bit of rush can spoil the whole animation. And the Shining Wizard seemed to be choppy and had some blurry pics. I loved the impact and the rope bounce was awesome. The effort you must have put into this. The shining wizard was slight stiff . I liked the back roll bit , that must have been the challenge for the move and the way you pulled it off was brilliant! Nice job! 8.7/10
Rob:Nice! The camera moved a little at the start but that always happens to me , I always kick the tripod leg by accident. I loved the kick that seemed really realistic and you must have gone into detail of the specific movements made by Cara in real life.The catch made by Punk was very well done . I liked the way you made Cara struggle by grabbing the post . The Back roll seemed slight fidgety ; it was going slight right a bit. But AMAZING job Rob. 9/10 Vote Rob! Nice match
|
|
|
Post by Cooperman on Apr 20, 2013 21:01:20 GMT -5
Angus : Stunning job man, this has to be my favorite non-flash ani from you. The Dropkick was really realistic, and so was the Chaos Theory. Smoothness & creativity were there as usual. I really liked the transition between the two suplexes which definitely made your ani. The few things that let your ani down were the chopiness (a bit - shining wizard) and the shadows.
Rob : First of, the build-up was really nice. I liked the kick and the jump. The catch was a nice touch. The move was mainly really smooth and flowed well but a better ediing would've made it better (fixing fidgetiness). The one thing that really let you down was the fact that the first suplex didn't have enough height. The impact was fine but more reaction wouldn't hurt. Can't find anything to be picky about otherwise.
Both did some great job, but yeah both had few flaws. Both had the creaitivty & the smoothness in their anis so to me, it's a draw.
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: May 14, 2024 21:02:21 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 20, 2013 22:56:34 GMT -5
Great animations from both you guys !
Angus: I liked the set-ups before the actual move. The dropkick was quite nice but the leg movements could've been bent more, but that wasn't part of the stip. The roll back was smooth and had a great speed, but I thought it was a little stiff. The German Suplex throw was very well done and i liked how you move Evan's movements before the landing. The impact seemed a bit awkward on how Evan bounced up, seemed a little unrealistic to me. The shining wizard at the end was very well done too, but still missing some frames.
Rob: This might be my favorite from you, I really like the kick to the face at the beginning of the video. Sin Cara's jump might've been a bit slow, but it was a good add to the animation. The roll was very nicely done and seemed realistic to me. The German Suplex was really nice and the reactions were realistically done. I saw a few frames with hands and shadows, not that big of a problem though.
Vote: This came really close, but I have to go with Rob.
|
|
|
Post by [The Ukrainian One] Dimburuk on Apr 21, 2013 1:38:49 GMT -5
Angus : i very like this animation, the running and the kick was pretty good, that figure is awesome for that hah, cool little reaction from Evan, roll-up was nice and smooth, the joint movements were good for that type of move, i really like the suplex itself as it's pretty smooth, not stiff, and had a very good impact, followed by a smooth kick, which was a bit stiff on Evan's side imo. Overall, great job on that.
Rob : The kick was good, reaction from Punk was fine but i don't like how he kinda doesn't move his arms or something, i just can't really say, i mean sin cara's jump over rope was fine, but Punk was doing something wrong at this moment, the roll up itself was pretty smooth but it was with weird positioning imo, and the suplex itself was good, but i felt the throw needed to be a bit more impactful, and i feel that reaction could be a bit better.
Vote : Angus, as i felt his had better joint movements and more better suplex part, with a nice reaction. Good job by both, awesome match!
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: May 14, 2024 21:02:21 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 21, 2013 3:53:25 GMT -5
I Don't really know how to vote for this one :S
|
|
|
Post by Andeh on Apr 21, 2013 6:02:36 GMT -5
I don't know who to vote for tbh. Both animations where fantastic. They where both so smooth and flowed so well. Nothing was unrealistic with them and the joint movements where great. Rob's had some fidgetyness with Cara at the beginning and lacked impact on the german in my opinion. Angus' had distracting shadows. They both have tiny flaws, but not enough to separate them for me. The only thing that makes me want to vote for Angus is the fact his reaction was better. But it was only better due to the fact he included a extra move that wasn't in the stip. There is adding a buildup and a reaction and then there is just adding moves that shouldn't be in there.
I cant decide between the two. So its a draw for me.
|
|
GAm3r357
Mid-Carder
Los Matadores.
Joined on: May 5, 2012 6:57:08 GMT -5
Posts: 111
|
Post by GAm3r357 on Apr 21, 2013 6:29:26 GMT -5
Woah...such a close match i dunno who to go for! Angus: Nice job here man the efforts you went to were great, but im going to concentrate on the main move (chaos theory) and the build up and try disregard your Shining wizard as its like the "aftershow" of the move . loved the running in the dropkick but the shadows in the top left corner of the wall annoyed me a little. The dropkick was nice but evans reaction off he ropes looked awkward. I think in the roll you had the positioning wrong. The legs should be on the outside rather than inside but, it still worked fine. I just think it seemed a little choppy causing it to be fast. Finally, evan didnt really connect with the mat. The reaction was great, and the impact looked good cause of the rope bounce but i failed to actually see evan full force hit the mat. good effort though, just slight rust still needed to be brushed off. 8/10 Rob: Really great job on this, few flaws though. The kick sin cara delivered was amazing. I rarely see that animated so it was great to see done! Punks reaction to it was a little weird though and unrealistic. LOVED caras jump over the ropes, that was so realisitc in the joint movement and then nice rope bounce to add to the impact coming off the jump. The catch was great and the walkign towards the turnbuckle wasnt fidgety at all. Loved the rolls and i preferred this way with punks legs on the outside rather than angus' who had them inside. I just think it looks bette coming up to the german in the way you pick him up. The rolls werent stiff really and flowed well - a little smoother than angus but i felt his joints were moved better. German was great but lacked impact. Reaction was nice having cara hold his back but punk couldve done with more of one. Also, shadows were seen on the ramp. Overall a very tough decision. Vote: Rob mainly because the rolls were smoother and flowed better than angus' and i liked his sin cara kick build up better than angus' dropkick. Great job guys.
|
|
|
Post by /X Metal Sorenges x "Mac Oh J~ on Apr 21, 2013 10:40:33 GMT -5
Very good match between Angus and Rob, it really is a tough one but I believe that Angus executed the Chaos Theory a bit better so I'll have to give my vote to Angus.
Rob: Very nice animation you have here Rob. At the start I like the idea behind the build-up but it didn't turn out as good as it could have been. CM Punk somewhat fidgets across the ring when he goes towards Sin Cara on the apron which takes away from the realism aspect of the animation. The side kick from Sin Cara on the apron was also a little bit fidgety and slow. I like the way CM Punk caught Sin Cara when he was going intending on going for the moonsault that looked very nice imo. I think it would have flowed a bit better if you had Sin Cara hold on the ropes and have CM Punk struggle a bit in a couple frames just to add to the quality of the ani as a whole. The rolling Chaos Theory was very nicely done, it looked very smooth throughout and neither Punk or Sin Cara looked stiff. The throw at the end was ok but it lacked impact and an effective rope bounce. 8.9/10
Angus: At the beginning I like the way you built-up for the Rolling Chaos Theory with the Daniel Bryan dropkick. The spacing in the running seemed a tad off and it was a little choppy but it didn't look bad at all. The dropkick looked smooth and Daniel Bryan didn't look stiff from either Evan Bourne or Daniel Bryan. I like the way you had D-Bry after the roll over push Bourne into the turnbuckle and set up for the rolling Chao Theory, the movements looked excellent in that portion of the ani in particular. For me, I thought it looked incredible how you had Bryan hovering over Bourne after the first roll, it must have been quite difficult to have them positioned right for that, it looked very realistic and the transition into the second flip was nearly perfect except I think you should have made him fall on his neck/head then roll backwards for impact rather then botched type of reaction somewhat. I like the rope bounce and impact I just feel Bourne could have definitely landed the move better. Nice finish with the step-up Enzigiri. 9.0/10
|
|
Ben
Mid-Carder
Joined on: Dec 12, 2012 22:07:00 GMT -5
Posts: 54
|
Post by Ben on Apr 21, 2013 10:48:39 GMT -5
Angus: Loved your animation with the corner drop kick and then the Chaos Theory was just beautiful. The only choppy part was at the end when Bryan gave Bourne a High Knee. Everything else flowed really well and I loved the reaction of the Chaos Theory.
Rob: Very Good setup with the kick And the springboard. In the Chaos Theory he didn't get thrown very far which I think he should because he has momentum from the back roll. But it flowed nicely and was not at all stiff.
Vote: Angus.
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: May 14, 2024 21:02:21 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 21, 2013 13:25:52 GMT -5
Angus the build up was nice but there were shadows and Evan was a bit fidgety the roll was nice but a bit stiff but the impact was great with the rope bounce and everything the post animation wasn't the greatest though I thought Bryan was stiff and Evan was kinda choppy when he turned around overall 7.5 out of 10
Rob the build up was kinda stiff and fidgety but it had a good flow to it, the roll was pretty good and a pretty good impact was made as well I know the stip was hard and I noticed it was fidgety in a few spots but ill give it a 7.7 out of 10
Vote Rob
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: May 14, 2024 21:02:21 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 21, 2013 14:13:47 GMT -5
I really dont know how I am going to judge this one fellas. It is very close, so i will do my best.
Angus - Very good job. This was a pretty smoothanimation you have here angus. You are still not quite at your best but you are gradually getting there. Loved the camera quality, shadows were a bit distracting and I saw no string ect. I liked the dropkick into the corner, was pretty smooth, had good joint movements, and liked evans reaction. I felt the Chaos Theory was decent itself. I felt some of the movements were a bit fidgety which kinda let you down. I really like the oversell by Bourne, nothing bad against it at all. Shining Wizard was pretty decent but I felt the impact and reaction was a bit choppy and lacked a few frames just to smooth it out a tad.
Rob - This was a good animation Rob. I liked the smoothness of the build up to your animation, the air time Cara got I thought was pretty realistic and had a nice flow to it. I felt Punks head could have had a greater movement after receiving the kick though if being harsh. I also thought some of Punks movements were a bit slidy for my liking. Really liked the catch into the set up of the move. Nice and smooth movements. I liked the smoothness of the move itself. It also had a nice flow and was less fidgety than Angus's I felt. I liked the movements of Sin Cara but I felt Punks legs were a bit stiff during the move, but that was only for the roll I felt, i liked the movements in the knee's during the throw. I liked the realism of the impact, after watching how the move is done on youtube, i felt you executed it well. I also liked the smoothness in the way Punk tossed Cara.
This is really damn close, i have re watcdhed several times to make sure I pick the valid winner. I would call this a draw if i was boring, but i like to pick a winner, so after re watching and thinking i will just VOTE ROB by the smallest bit because i felt his chaos theory was less fidgety, and the fact that both guys "Extra Moves" had a similar amount of flaws in them.
|
|
wwestevo07
Main Eventer
4 Time WF Ani World Champion
Joined on: Oct 17, 2006 14:15:28 GMT -5
Posts: 1,142
|
Post by wwestevo07 on Apr 22, 2013 12:02:48 GMT -5
Angus: The dropkick looked great, really smooth and realistic movements. Was a good idea to setup the move. The roll started off good but just as Bryan is rolling into the suplex its kind of hard to explain but to me it looked a little more like Bryan sort of flipped up into it rather than a smooth roll if that makes sense lol. The suplex was smooth and looked great. Bourne's reaction seemed a little weird when he hit the mat but it was still a nice reaction. The shining wizard was great, really smooth and nice reaction by Bourne.
Rob: The kick at the start looked pretty good and smooth but it looked a little slow, would have looked even better just a tiny bit faster and Punk could of had more of a reaction to it. I loved the jump into the ring by Cara and punk grabbing him, it looks great and was a nice build up. For the roll into the suplex i feel yours was more of a realistic roll and was also smooth. The suplex was smooth and flowed well but i think it would have looked better if it had a little more height. Reactions were nice.
Really close match. Was pretty hard to pick a winner because everything was pretty much matched but the only thing i could find was that i thought Rob had more of a realistic roll into the suplex so because it was so matched that's the only real thing i can base it on so vote: Rob
|
|