WF Animania XI - Match 1

[Deleted]

Vote ASMI,
ASMI- You had more creativity and really good build up, the climbing looked a little fidgety, but it did look hard to do. The move was a little bit stiff and the impact was good, but the reaction could of been better.

Josh- You not having build up was kind of disappointing, I found the animation to be a little stiff but mostly smooth. The impact was good but the reaction looked weird.

Very good animations from you both, but I feel that ASMI put more time into his animation than Josh

[wwestevo07]

Josh: Would have been nice to add a little build up like Orton getting onto the rope first but nothing major. The suplex was done great. It was really smooth and flowed well and i liked the movements especially Orton coming off the rope. The reactions were pretty good, i liked Ziggler's better than Orton's. Also might have been better if you tried to remove the string. The animation was great overall but think it would have looked even better if you could have made it a little faster.

ASMI: Really liked the build up but the kick looked a bit choppy as was the climb up to the ropes but i know how hard that would be. The suplex look good but i think it could have done with an extra frame or two. The impact was great and i liked Sin Cara's reaction it was smooth and looked good. I feel Bourne should have bounced a little more when he hit the mat.

Vote: Josh, two good animations but i felt ASMI's suplex was just a bit more choppy than Josh's.

[Scotty]

Great job by both of you. Josh, your animation was incredibly smooth. The only fidgety parts I could see was dolphs left hand as he was getting lifted. Orton's movements while coming down were not stiff at all. Dolphs movements though were stiff and his knee joints should have been bended more. The reaction and bump was nice, but looked a bit strange and they both slid.
Asami did a nice job as well, although I don't condone the use of Mattys in his video. The kick was a little fidgety, and the string tied to the turnbuckles bothered me. I like how you had the liftup though, The suplex was smooth but a little stiff, and the reaction was way overdone and unrealistic. Gonna go with Josh on this one as his was more smooth and less stiff.

[el torro]

What an even match here.

Josh: Really like this animation, you did a really nice job. The whole thing overall was incredibly smooth however during the lift, both Ziggler and Orton looked pretty stiff. The fall was looking nice up until the impact. I wasn't a big fan of the three camera changes as it made the ani look sort of out of place. The reaction from Ziggler looked fine but I think Orton could've done something else.

ASMI: Wow man, really great job on this! Did not expect that outta you. The buildup in the beginning was a really nice touch and rope climbing was a really nice touch however a tad choppy. The suplex itself wasn't as smooth as Josh's, but had a real nice reaction. Good job.

In the end, it really comes down to smoothness vs. creativity. As much as Josh's ani looked great, I feel like ASMI put more effort into this ani so for that reason, my vote goes to ASMI.

[Deleted]

I vote Josh because it feels smother and i like the camera angles

[BION]

great match, but ASMI gets my vote.

I thought ASMI had pretty creative build up with the superkick and the lift up onto the middle rope. I thought his animation had a good flow throughout the suplex and build up itself, the speed helped it alot. Also the reaction from Cara was good.


Josh, your animation was not your best imo. I thought it was really smooth just like they always are but it seemed to be a little slow which was one of the things that made me vote for asmi in this match. I felt in the suplex that ziggler was a little stiff, in the reaction the camera angle change distracted me. The reaction also looked unfinished.

[/X Metal Sorenges x "Mac Oh J~]

It looks like it's 10-10 from my count, I excluded two votes in this entire match. Extreme2213 and steely200, they lack detail within the vote and length.

[Deleted]

Apr 22, 2013 13:35:50 GMT -5 /X Metal Sorenges x "Mac Oh J~ said:

It looks like it's 10-10 from my count, I excluded two votes in this entire match. Extreme2213 and steely200, they lack detail within the vote and length.

Um count again i have 11

[Ross]

Apr 22, 2013 13:35:50 GMT -5 /X Metal Sorenges x "Mac Oh J~ said:

It looks like it's 10-10 from my count, I excluded two votes in this entire match. Extreme2213 and steely200, they lack detail within the vote and length.

Steely200, TheUndertaker96, KKD, ewfianimations, extreme2213 and Ben's vote don't count due to lack of detail/Jobber votes.

[Deleted]

Its 9-9 atm. Ross to confirm, the title gets shared if it is a draw? i believe that happened in the past?

[Cooperman]

Apr 22, 2013 14:47:13 GMT -5 @fireballx90 said:

Its 9-9 atm. Ross to confirm, the title gets shared if it is a draw? i believe that happened in the past?

IMO, if it's a draw, give the match few more hours so the tie can be broken. better than having two champs, but again, that's just my opinion.

[Leones]

If it's a draw the champion retains...

[Deleted]

Apr 22, 2013 15:02:57 GMT -5 Leones said:

If it's a draw the champion retains...

That doesnt happen here. Past results have shown that.

[Leones]

Apr 22, 2013 15:06:41 GMT -5 @fireballx90 said:

Apr 22, 2013 15:02:57 GMT -5 Leones said:

If it's a draw the champion retains...

That doesnt happen here. Past results have shown that.

Oh okay... So what happens?

[Deleted]

By the looks of it, Taker fella modified his vote. If i am not mistaken that is 10-9 to Asmi now.

Damn, what a match.