Ross
Main Eventer
Joined on: Nov 21, 2008 9:43:29 GMT -5
Posts: 3,154
|
Post by Ross on Apr 11, 2013 16:04:50 GMT -5
"The Animania Pre Show is about to begin!" High Flyers Title 1# ContenderKKD Vs. #Showoff Vs. SuperbradOpig Vs. TheViper9o21o -Stip: Springboard second rope DDT KKD: #Showoff: i.minus.com/ibd4LTahaj0QnB.gifSuperbradOpig: i1270.photobucket.com/albums/jj611/bcwrestling5/DDT4GIF_zps7c80f5f5.gifTheViper9o21o: i.minus.com/inD8QhtRAdGW3.gifHow to vote on matches: No polls and no suckish replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following: 1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?) 2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended) If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions. Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match. VOTING ENDS IN 48 HOURS
|
|
Dan.
Main Eventer
Joined on: May 5, 2009 12:46:28 GMT -5
Posts: 1,989
|
Post by Dan. on Apr 11, 2013 16:27:11 GMT -5
Let me just say, this is a very close match.
But... I'm voting for TheViper.
KKD: Let me just say, I really like this animation. The whole thing flowed really damn well, it was smooth, the jump was great, the turn was well done, but I can't help but think the reaction was a little odd. I also think you should've changed camera angle because the ropes obscured the impact. Nice work though.
Showoff: This is also a damn nice animation. There wasn't anything really wrong with this actually, I loved Kendrick's (?) reaction, the only thing I have to say is that it was slightly too slow. Thats it. Nice stuff man.
SuperbradOpig: Not bad man, I think the camera angle you used was nice, the movements were fine, I just think you need to move the figures by the same amount on each picture to help it flow better. Unfortunately I saw string, and try not to animate in front on something reflective like glass because I could pretty clearly see you holding the string. Not bad though, you have potential.
Viper: Loved it. The flow, the speed, the movements, reaction, near perfect. There's hardly anything I can comment about this animation besides the fact I saw string. Nice job.
|
|
|
Post by wwextreme25 on Apr 11, 2013 17:46:27 GMT -5
KKdarden: Not bad mate, i liked this one but it wasnt your best. I liked the springboard, it had nice joint movement but not loads, and flowed well. I think you need to over exaggerate your joint movements a bit more. Although they're good, they're not THAT noticable so maybe move them a bit more on over exaggerate them for them to become more fluid and noticable - similar to that RKo ani you've previously made. Also, in the ddt edges legs were very stiff however the whole flow of the animation was great and was very smooth so good job.
Showoff: Springboard was nice man - good joint movements again, and i liked the speed however i thought the whole animation was too slow and needed to be sped up more to look like a more realistic speed. Especially in the ddt. The joints were moved well - very similar to kkdardens movements - but i think the speed of this let it down as it looked very slow in the ddt and therefore lacked impact. Also Kendrick??* was a little fidgety in the reactino but good effort
superbrad: Not your greatest animation. There wasnt really any springboard? the animation just started with a frame of bryan halfway up the ropes which looked odd. Bryans movements in mid air were really strange and had no real direction to it. Also, i think it was stiff, and lacked flow. The speed wasnt very lifelike either. The spin in the ddt was nice however, you kinda wetn back on yourself. You started to spin bryan down to get a spin into the ddt but then he came back towards the corner again which i thought went "against the flow" and spoilt it a bit. But yeah, i thought show offs and kkdardens were better due to the flow and smoothness. Keep practising tho.
Theviper: I really liked this animation man. The speed in this is the kinda speed kkdarden and showoff were lacking. However what they lack in some areas, you lack in others. Your springboard was nice and had good flow, but then during the rope bounce, coming off the ropes after the jump, there seemed to be a missing frame which ruined he flow and made a chopy kinda look to the animation, The ddt was nice and had good flow but a little stiff. I could tell you moved dolphs legs but then you kinda stopped moving them half way when you shouldve continued. Not a bad animation but not your best, Keep it up though you're improving.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Vote: kkdarden.
Reason: The speed of showoffs ani let him down and was unrealistic, and a few other minor flaws such as the odd missing frame, and slight stiffnedd which is what edged kkdardens over his.
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: Mar 28, 2024 16:39:55 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Apr 11, 2013 18:34:53 GMT -5
KKD: Nice animation man! The animation needed more frames as a whole but still had a nice flow, the movements were great, my only complaints regarding movement is that Dolph was stiff when falling down in the DDT, the reaction was really nice and had good fluid movements, the lighting wasn't great and there were continual shadows, it was still a nice animation.
7/10
#Showoff: Good animation here man! It had a great flow through-out, but could've used a few more pictures at certain points, Gabriel was really stiff in the falling down of the DDT, Kendrick also was stiff in mid-air, I liked the reaction even though it wasn't as big as KKD's, the lighting was perfect, stiffness really got ya, good stuff.
5.5/10
SuperbradOpig: Not bad here mate. It needed quite a lot more pictures, it was very fidgety and needed a better flow too it, both Dolph and Bryan were very stiff through-out and lacked movement, they really needed to be moved more, I like that you added a little reaction but it needed more, landing on your head like that would hurt like hell, act like it's happening in real life and base it off a real move, the lighting/camera quality was perfect as always but the pictures seemed to slide up and down for some reason.
2.5/10
Viper: Really nice animation by your standards. It was nice and had a good flow through-out, however, Dolph was stiff through-out the whole move as was Gabriel in the falling, Dolph had a very small reaction and should've held onto his head in pain, the lighting was very good but I did see some small pieces of string, nice animation.
5.5/10
Vote: KKD
|
|
|
Post by /X Metal Sorenges x "Mac Oh J~ on Apr 11, 2013 18:59:36 GMT -5
My vote goes to KKDarden on this one.
SuperbradOpig: Very nice attempt you have there Superbrad. At the beginning the there wasn't any type of bend or squat to show that Bryan is getting any momentum into the turn for the 720 DDT, the way the ani led up to the to the move itself without any significant build up looked really unrealistic. The jumping turn at the start looked very fidgety, choppy and a tad stiff. Ziggler was really stiff and he wasn't moving consistency throughout the ani which didn't flow very well. The 720 DDT itself was stiff and it lacked many frames and it was fidgety in mid air. The impact was ok but I didn't like how Daniel Bryan's head did a 180 degree turn at the end. 6.8/10
TheViper9o21o: Nice animation you have here Viper. At the beginning I really like the squat before the initial jump, it looked very realistic, and it flowed well, it was smooth and the speed looked perfect. I think you could have made the transition from the rope look a bit smooth with a few more frames of his toes slowly moving off as it didn't look right the way he flew of the ropes so quick. The turn into the 720 DDT had great joint movement, the spacing was very nicely done and it was rather smooth as well but just a tad fast. The 720 DDT was the best part of the ani it was very smooth and the joint movement was very nice, perhaps you could have over exaggerated Dolph Ziggler's joint movement a little bit to make impact look better but it was fine as it is. The reaction at the end could have been better though. 8.4/10
Showoff: I really like this animation here Showoff. At the beginning I thought the bend into the springboard was very nicely done, it had a good amount of frames and the joint movement was superb. The springboard itself was good and I'm glad to see that you got the transition from the middle rope into the turn to look smooth without having fidgetiness or choppiness involved. In mid air the joint movement could have been better as with Gabriel's arms and legs were slightly bent which gave the air time portion of the ani a bit of a floatiness. I think what would really have helped out your ani here was the speed of the 720 DDT was the speed, it seemed a bit to slow which really killed the momentum the ani had going on. The joint movement from both was nearly perfect imo and the impact and reaction were personally one of my favorites. 8.6/10
KKD: This has to be one of my favorite ani's from you KKDarden. At the beginning I really like the squat before jump, it was very smooth although it could have been a little bit lower. I like the way you had Ziggler swing his arms back to get momentum into the turn, it flowed very well and it looked pretty smooth, it did look a tad floaty but that is hardly noticeable. The speed in air time was generally the best out of everyone in this match, it made the 720 DDT flow a bit better and the oversell with the Edge bouncing off his head had that touch to your ani which really clinched the win for you imo. The impact was great, I really like the effective rope bounce and nice reactions at the end. 8.7/10
|
|
|
Post by Cooperman on Apr 12, 2013 17:20:21 GMT -5
Came down to #Showoff & KKD.
KKD : Amazing ani man. You did so well with the joints movements though you used basics. I guess you took enough pics as it didn't look choppy. I liked the oversell and the move had some impact. Nothing much to say about it.
#Showoff : Wasn't too bad. The beginning looked pretty good. Was quite smooth and not really choppy. Things got weird when Gabriel picked Kendrick's head for the DDT. Looks like you took too many pics in that part compared to the build-up. Could have been solved if you played around with the speed. One more thing that let you down is the stiffness. Reaction was fine otherwise.
I vote for KKD.
|
|