No polls and no suckish replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following:
1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?)
2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended)
If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.
Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.
VOTING ENDS IN 48 HOURS
"Two blackbirds on a highway sign..."
WF Animation Accomplishments: Former Moderator
Hall of famer
1x World Champion
2x Tag team Champion
1x European Champion
1x High Flyers Champion
1x Hardcore Champion
Slammy Award Winner
Post by /X Metal Sorenges x "Mac Oh J~ on Jan 27, 2013 18:47:55 GMT -5
My vote goes to Thememan and Scott.
ThememanXX: Really good animation you have here Thememan. I like the way at the beginning of the animation you motioned Big Show to lift up Sin Cara for the Ragnorok. The lift was really smooth and I didn't spot very much stiffness. The flip into the slam from the Big Show's had great joint movement and the slam had a good amount of impact while maintaining it's smoothness. I don't like the way Tyson just slid across to the turnbuckle after the lift, it didn't look realistic and it took away from the quality of the animation as a whole but the reaction from Sin Cara was very nice 8.7/10
Scott: Pretty decent animation here Scott. The walking from Kevin Steen looked somewhat stiff and rather slow mostly. The flip itself was alright but Batman looked a little stiff during the flip into the slam. The Hulk and Hornswaggle had fine movements but Batman didn't really have a reaction at the end. 8.5/10
Adam: The running at the beginning of the animation appeared to bit just a little bit fidgety and imo just a bit awkward looking. The lift into the Ranorok was pretty good, Sin Cara didn't seem stiff throughout the flip and the slam bit it could have used an extra 1-2 frames and neither did CM Punk or Dolph Ziggler. Nice reaction from Sin Cara as well. 8.6/10
Josh: The running at the beginning seemed to be just a tad slow. John Morrison could have used a few more pictures after pushing the legs back though, but the lift and slam was ok, the distance Mysterio traveled in the slam didn't seem really realistic and both Ryder and Ted were a little stiff. 8.5/10
Nice Animation Scott, it made me laugh when i first saw it. Steens walking looked pretty good i guess if anything a bit slow. I liked the movement of Batman's head when Steen was a nice touch. I thought some of Hulk's movements were quite fidgety in his feet which kinda let it down a bit. I liked the movements of Hulk and Hornswoggle bringing batman down, they were pretty smooth. Steen looked like he put a bit of effort into his throw which was nice but what really spoiled the animation for me is the change of the camera angle, it kinda ruined the flow for me a bit. Batman was pretty smooth through mid air but he lacked a reaction in the end. The quality was nice but the string was pretty noticeable nearer the end.
This was a really good animation, one of your better ones. I really liked the build up to your animation. It was a nice touch to add and was the best out of everyone's in that aspect. The taunts from Tyson were also very nice and had a good flow to them and were smooth. The running was very slidey though which let you down a bit. Although it had a good flow it was pretty unrealistic. I thought the fall of Sin Cara was a bit slow at the start but sped up nicely through mid air and was very smooth and had a nice flow. I liked the effort you put into Tyson's reaction, it had nice impact into the turnbuckle but was pretty unrealistic. The lighting was good apart from one slight change at the start of the animation, i saw no shadows and the string wasn't very evident.
Not Bad from you here Adam. The walking at the start seemed pretty awkward and didn't have a great flow to it really. The movement into the toss was good but the throw of Sin Cara seemed kinda delayed to me. The movements of Ziggler and Punk in the toss movement were okay they just seemed a bit fidgety to me but not to bad. I thought Sin Cara was a bit floaty in mid air as well as being a bit stiff. The reaction of Sin Cara was nice and I also liked the reaction of Punk, Ziggler and Heath, just a bit fidgety for me. The Quality of the animation was pretty good, but the shadows were a bit distracting for me. The string wasnt to clear. Well Done.
Good Job Joshua. The quality was really nice, the string wasn't to evident at all here and the camera was still throughout and there wasn't any distracting shadows. I liked the walking to your animation, it was smooth and had a good flow to it. I liked how Jo Mo pushed Rey up, very smooth and had a nice flow and realism. The toss was very smooth also and had a really nice flow to it. I liked the movements of Ted and Ryder in the toss, they were pretty smooth, however right at the end i found a couple of their movements a wee bit fidgety. Still a really good job here josh.
Really Close Here. But after counting up the errors in both sets of animations I am going to just give this one to Josh and Adam.
Thememan : I liked how you showed the Big Shows lifting the victim unlike the other anis, who directly had both guys lifting the figure. The taunt by Kidd before the push was a great add. The Rangnarok itself wasn't really bad but it would've been better if you had Tyson walking instead of sliding. 8/10
Scott : Nice ani Scott. The walking wasn't bad, but I mainly liked how you had Steen walking after the push, unlike the rest. The flip was smooth, and the taunts from Horny and Steen were nice. Not much of reaction from Batman but I understand it doesn't have deluxe joints. You though needed to work on stiffness mostly. Really not bad though. 7.75/10
Ps : really love those DC figs, you should use them more!
Overall team mark : 15.75/20
Josh : Nice animation here. Was pretty good, smooth & flowed well. As usual, it had great source of light, didn't notice strings and was a bit realistic but you screwed up in the push. You just had JoMo sliding which ruined it. Impact was decent but it lacked a reaction. Not much to say about it, 7.5/10
Adam : Not bad, but looks like you still have troubles fixing fidgetiness. It was the main problem in your ani, and it unfortunately ruined it. It was a bit stiff as well but besides that, it didn't look that bad. Good you had a nice light. The flip was fine and the taunts after the Ragnarok were nicely added. Just try editing strings next time. 6.75/10
Overall team mark : 14.25/20
I vote for Scott & Thememan.
Last Edit: Jan 29, 2013 16:55:07 GMT -5 by Cooperman