Post by wwextreme25 on Dec 2, 2012 16:58:58 GMT -5
"Can Josh Hang on to the title, or will XBLkid cause an upset"
European Championship Match
"THE XBLKID" vs *Josh (C)
~Stip: Top rope Release German Suplex
How to vote on matches:
No polls and no suckish replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following:
1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?)
2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended)
If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.
Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.
VOTING ENDS IN 48 HOURS!
Animation Profile: 1x World Heavyweight Champion
2x High Flyers Champion (Longest Reigning)
1x Entrance King Champion (Longest Reigning)
3x Slammy Award Winner
1x Money in the bank winner
Josh I didn't like the angle or the way the animation started it was smooth until the impact where you were missing a photo or two and no reaction 6 out of10
XBL didn't care for the build up and you didn't really do the stop right this was really just a normal German suplex not a top rope release one it was smooth though did see a a good amount of wire 5 out of 10
Josh: For some strange gingerbread man reason, I like this animation. Probably cause of the angle(and Kurt Angle ;D). The throw was nice, it was smooth aside from Anderson missing a frame during the suplex. The main problems were stiffness in Anderson's legs, Anderson/Angle barely having a reaction, and no build up.
XBL: Not your best, also switch back to your blue background. >:l I liked how you had build up, but there were small errors(background turning slightly red, the box, the dot on the background, etc) that kinda ruined it for me. Cody's legs were really stiff, I suggest cutting off his knee pads, they are terrible to animate with. The ani flowed well, but the main issues were stiffness, and that the German wasn't from the top/middle rope, that Cody was just sitting on the top rope. But I liked that yours had more of a reaction.
Vote: I'm going with Josh here because of his not having small errors that shouldn't be there like XBL's ani has, and that his German was from the middle/top ropes, unlike XBL's.
Post by /X Metal Sorenges x "Mac Oh J~ on Dec 2, 2012 21:47:35 GMT -5
My vote goes to Josh.
Josh: Great animation you have here Josh. That assistance mechanism you have perched over the ring always ceases to amaze me, anyways, onto the animation. The animation was really nicely done, the suplex was incredibly smooth throughout but you missed maybe one or two frames in the air time with Kennedy and the other with Angle. Not much I could really say bad about the ani other then those two things. Good job! 9.5/10
THEXBLKID: I really like the idea you tried to portray in this animation here XBLKID unfortunately your attempt didn't flow as best as it could and it could have used much more height and elevation. At the beginning the jump onto the top rope was a little smooth but you could have bent Rhodes knees a bit more before the jump. The way DH Smith pulled down Cody and land square on the turnbuckle looked really really odd, it's somewhat hard to give you pointers at the segment of the ani but it lacked realism and smoothest. The suplex was stiff from both DH and Rhodes and I didn't see the release part that you assumed Josh of missing so I not sure if this ani is complete or not? anyways good effort. 7.8/10
Josh: Very nice animation here mate, the set up was very nice, I love how Kurt was positioned. The throw was very smooth, I really like how they both feel at the same time which was very realistic. Kurt Angle And Mr.Anderson were missing frames when they're about to land. But that's the only flaw I saw here, besides the couple frames which had strings. 8.5/10
XBLkid:[/b] The animation was smooth, along with the set up. I really like how you had the build up to for the move, it was very realistic. When Rhodes feel down on top of the turnbuckle, that should've used more frames. The ring was also shakey, you should fix the problem by simply just putting blue tack under it. The camera wasn't that shaky. The German suplex was stiff how DH Smith just feel back the way you animate him. Good job though. 7.8/10
Josh : Good Animation here bro! As we come to expect lighting was very good and the animation was pretty smooth. I really liked the angle to. The animation jumped a bit in mid air as you lacked some frames which made it seem a bit choppy just in that section. Angle also seemed a bit stiff in his legs after the release suplex and the reactions were kinda lacking but good job. 7.9/10
XBL : Not your best but still good. You had a bit of build up unlike Josh which was cool into the move. Nice Touch. Just small things went wrong here bro. Cody's legs were very stiff in this ani and I also saw a box or leg? at the end of the animation as well as wire which put me of a bit. 6.2/10
Mainly because his ani was smoother, less stiff (well not that brilliant, but I didn't feel the stiffness as much in his ani as in xbl's ani), had better angle, and mostly because he had both figs standing on the ropes which was a real challenge. Sorry xbl, if you only improved your angles, used a better ring and worked on stiffness, it would've been much better. Also, use your blue background instead. This one makes your anis look so darkish.
Josh: A little build up before the suplex would have been nice. The suplex it self was smooth, might of been a missing frame or something before they landed but it wasn't that noticeable. The reaction was all right but i feel like it needed more of a reaction since they are falling from the ropes. Anderson should have had more of a bounce or maybe rolled over.
THEXBLKID: It wasnt really how the stip was suppose to be done but anyways, i liked how u added a build up. It was somewhat smooth for most of the ani but also quite stiff. I liked Cody's reaction. For me there was way too many camera angle changes in this which i think dosn't look good, try having the camera further out more so you don't have to keep changing it and you can see whats going on.
Vote: Josh. It was more smooth, less stiff and the camera didn't keep changing like Xblkid's did.