Summer Catastrophe: MATCH 6

[Deleted]

"It is almost time for one of the biggest matches of all time, but how can we leave out the talented high flyers of animation?!"



High Flyers Championship

Mister Favian* vs The Firelord: RYRY vs The XBLKID* vs Wwextreme25(c)*
-Stip: Corkscrew spaceman plancha




Favian:



The XBLKID:



wwextreme25:



How to vote on matches:

No polls and no suckish replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following:

1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?)

2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended)

If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.

Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.




VOTING ENDS IN 48 HOURS

[Deleted]

Fave running was great but I thought there should of been more space between each step the move itself was perfect good reaction and loved the creativity 9 out 10

The XBL not your best arms were stiff and there was a lot of wire and no reaction 6 out of 10

Rob nice ani your running was perfect the shadows were pretty distracting though didn't edit the wires like Fave and you had a great reaction good job 8.5 out of 10


Vote Fave

[coop]

This obviously came down to Rob & Fave, but I vote for Rob.

Rob had an amazing running/build-up.I loved how realistic and smooth it was. The top rope jump was pretty good. I like the move itself, but you had a little space between Eddie's legs and that's what I didn't like. Though, to me, it was clearly better than Fave's. In Fave's ani, the build-up wasn't that good. It wasn't realistic, the running didn't have the same distance between each step & it was a bit fidgety. Overall, didn't flow well. The move itself was fine. Still, I liked it only cause you didn't have the space between the legs but otherwise, Rob's is still better. It lacked reaction and impact wasn't noticeable while Rob had a decent impact and reaction. Also, one of the things that made me chose Rob's was the fact that he had a better source of light because in Fave's, I couldn't even see well what's happening. Also, these taunts/moves from both figs in the beginning were a nice touch. Overall, just love how wwextreme25's turned out!

[Fave]

How did my build-up suck?

[Scotty]

Aug 11, 2012 23:47:33 GMT -5 @coop said:

This obviously came down to Rob & Fave, but I vote for Rob.

Rob had an amazing running/build-up, but the move itself wasn't great. In Fave's ani, the build-up sucked, but the move itself was excellent. Though, it lacked reaction and impact wasn't noticeable while Rob had a decent impact. Also, one of the things that made me chose Rob's was the fact that he had a better source of light because in Fave's, I couldn't even see well what's happening. Also, these taunts/moves from both figs in the beginning were a nice touch. Overall, just love how wwextreme25's turned out!

Sorry to be "that guy" But your vote makes no sense. The stip is Corkscrew spaceman plancha so how can you say Fave had a better move but vote Rob?.....
#SomeoneButtHurt


Fave: THe running was nice but seemed a little like hopping :l3
No string is seeen and the running wasn't stiff. But this isn't about the running, its about the Screwman Pancho. Evan had realistic movements during it, and Tyson had incredbily realistic movements and was not stiff. The reaction was nice but could hace been a bit better.
XboxLiveBoy: You really gotta get a lower tripod bro. String was seen, The move was fidgety and the walking looked strange. The pancho was unrealistic and his movements were stiff. There was a small reaction that was fidgety and shakey.
Ron: The taunt and running was a nice touch, String was seen though and dolph was really fidgety and had kind of random movements. Eddie was a little fidgety mid air but the reaction was brilliant.
Really close between Fave and Ron but fave gets my vote here, Rons had a better reaction and running but the actual stipulation fave animated much better.

[Fave]

Aug 12, 2012 0:31:19 GMT -5 @coop said:

Your running was your build-up basically, and it sucked. Look, it isn't even realistic. The joints movement are different and they don't flow well together. I mean, just compare to Rob's. Plus you didn't even animate the correct stip, lighting sucked, and there was nearly no impact. Next time you wanna play that I know everything guy Scott, know what you're about to tell before talking trash. I don't wanna spam the thread for now.

My running is better than any animation you've ever made so i guess that basically means you've never made any good animations? Show me a video of someone doing the stip correctly because there is nothing to compare it to so i based it off what i thought looked correct. As for the lighting..yes i agree its too dark but i made it that way on purpose due to my lighting being too bright. Though you said my corkscrew plancha was better yet you voted for rob because of his build-up. Your vote therefore makes no sense. That's all i have to say.

[Deleted]

Fave: Really good animation, very smooth through-out, but seemed to miss a few frames in the corkscrew part, the joints were moved really well through-out, it was weirdly stiff with the pauses, I liked the reaction but the way it was delayed was really weird, would've been better if it just showed Jericho then the reaction instead of the 2 different angles then Jericho then reaction, saw no string or shadows and no other imperfections.

TheXBLKid: The animation was alright, was smooth for the most part but still needed a few pictures at certain times, Jericho was really stiff, looked as though he knew it was coming and didn't give a f*ck about being hit with the move, Jomo was stiff when he was on the top rope, I would've liked more of a reaction from Jericho, saw some string but no shadows, the shaky camera was annoying.

Rob: Really nice animation, very smooth through-out, The joints were moved very well but maybe a bit too much for Dolph before the move, the reaction was really nice, I really liked the camera angles as well, I saw a few shadows and some string, but they weren't very distracting, still a good animation.

Vote: Fave

Would've voted Rob if he had've moved Dolph a little less and got rid of the shadows and string.

[wwextreme25]

Aug 12, 2012 0:40:23 GMT -5 Fave said:

Aug 12, 2012 0:31:19 GMT -5 @coop said:

Your running was your build-up basically, and it sucked. Look, it isn't even realistic. The joints movement are different and they don't flow well together. I mean, just compare to Rob's. Plus you didn't even animate the correct stip, lighting sucked, and there was nearly no impact. Next time you wanna play that I know everything guy Scott, know what you're about to tell before talking trash. I don't wanna spam the thread for now.

My running is better than any animation you've ever made so i guess that basically means you've never made any good animations? Show me a video of someone doing the stip correctly because there is nothing to compare it to so i based it off what i thought looked correct. As for the lighting..yes i agree its too dark but i made it that way on purpose due to my lighting being too bright. Though you said my corkscrew plancha was better yet you voted for rob because of his build-up. Your vote therefore makes no sense. That's all i have to say.

you have a go at me for bitching, now look what you're doing...

[wwextreme25]

i may aswell just give you the title now if you're going to be that bothered about any vote someone gives against me, just so i can shut you up from complaining.

And scott why is it every match i seem to have, if you dont like my ani and someone votes for me, you complain to them and say its wrong, robs sucked your vote is wrong and your logic is wrong". cause imo what you're doing there, is wrong. it doesnt concern you...

[GAm3r357]

Fave: No offence, but compared to your last rope runnning ani, this is terrible. It isnt really running as he just kinda hops along...maybe make the strides bigger next time and ver exaggerate the joints like you did with bourne. The move itself was a little weird. It al went too quick and i could honestly not see which way tyson was turning to deliver the move. it was all a blur i think it was a little stiff in the turn also. LOVED the way tyson connectedwith bourne though like, when they fell back i just didnt like the way they stopped dead after hitting the chair. ADD AN OVERSELL MAN make this move what it should be. The added frames after the move as unecessary and just needed a good reaction. wasnt bad but needs a bit of work here and there. 7/10

Rob: LOVED the beginning movements from Dolph. Very smooth and looked realistic (like he was holding his head or something) Eddies taunt looked a little quick but once again, you did well with the running. my favourite part here HAS TO BE the climb up the ropes. LOOKED so realistic the way he jumped one footed on the middle, then onto the top - great joint movement there! The Twist in mid air looked more realistic to me than faves did as in the movements. It was a little choppier compared to faves however, it was still a good animation and was easy to see what was happening and again, like faves, i LOVED the connection between eddie and dolph. The coming together of them both as they fell was great. Dolph was a ilttle fidgety but not too much and maybe edit string next time but it wasnt overly noticable. 7.5/10

I gave rob the extra 0.5 to get 7.5/10 because the running was nicer, the rope climb was excellent and closer to the stip cara does and although the mid air was slightly choppy, it looked nice and had GREAT joint movement. Also rob's had the best reaction. So the extra .5 goes to rob.

An overall good match.

VOTE: ROB

[Wardyz]

Wow... very close match

Fave : Amazing job! Unlike most of the people voting, I loved the build up (as it was more creative and difficult) but maybe a bit skippy... Very smooth and surprisingly not fidgety, great twist during the plancha but Tyson landed almost with his back (positive and negative) the reaction was nice but I hated the pauses, I'd rather have jericho on commentary at the end.

XBLKID : Your best but clearly out matched by the pros... it was smooth but a tiny bit fidgety and very stiff... It was kinda strange the way JoMo landed with his arms but they were very stiff... Jericho didn't really react.

Rob : Shame that you could remake it... As a whole, very smooth, not too stiff and at a nice speed... main problems was the fidgetiness with dolph at the start of the animation... the occasional shadows which were very distracting and the camera angle changes... reaction was alright.

Vote : Fave

[Fave]

Aug 12, 2012 4:42:48 GMT -5 wwextreme25 said:

i may aswell just give you the title now if you're going to be that bothered about any vote someone gives against me, just so i can shut you up from complaining.

And scott why is it every match i seem to have, if you dont like my ani and someone votes for me, you complain to them and say its wrong, robs sucked your vote is wrong and your logic is wrong". cause imo what you're doing there, is wrong. it doesnt concern you...

I'm not bothered by the fact that he voted for you. I'm bothered by the fact that coop said my build-up SUCKED. He doesn't even know how to use that term correctly. In all the matches he's voted on if he doesn't like one aspect of it then it automatically SUCKS. That's what he said and it pisses me off because he doesn't give any reasoning. Also you complained any time someone voted for me in our singles title's match because you said they were degrading your ani. I on the other hand am not trying to change his vote but rather replying to his nonsense.

[Deleted]

Legend

[Deleted]

Clearly came down to Rob and Fave:D

Fave: Great animation Nice Running reminds me on robs running. Looks great how he jumps off. it was really smooth and i didnt see string. Oh and I like how kidd puts his arms together during the corkscrew looks great 8/10

Rob: Nice Animation. I think that your running isn't like it used to be :s smooth but I saw string. Please work on editing your sting. those 5 minutes are necessary... they kinda destroy the animation. 7/10

Vote: Misteeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeer Faviiiiaaaaaaaaaaaaan........ Faviiaan!

[jwsowner]

Fave: Wow, your arena is dark...Awesome job. Very creative. I love the running. The corkscrew was done very well. I like how the fell into the chairs. Great reaction, lol at the Jeri-Cole....Too many camera angles, though. :/ 8.5/10

XBLKID: Smooth, running could be better. The corkscrew happened too late. 7/10

Rob: I saw string. Smooth, awesome running as expected. I like the corkscrew. Best reaction of all 3 animations. 8.5/10

I vote Rob. Even though I saw string, it was easier to follow and it had the best reaction.

[Ross]

I vote for Rob in this one, I may be wrong but the "spaceman" part of the stip is the jumps up to the top rope and he actually followed the stip where as Favian ran along the top rope, which I liked but you missed out a part of the stip.

Rob, I like your running alot and I like how you made Bourne climb the ropes. The corkscrew was great and you had the best reaction of all the people in this match. I didn't like how you could see string and I wasn't a big fan on how Bourne crouched before he jumped of the top rope Fave, your animation was great but as I said earlier, you didn't follow the stip. XBLKID, Your animation isn't bad but you could improve on your running and the stiffness in your animation.

[wwextreme25]

Aug 13, 2012 6:57:54 GMT -5 Ross said:

I vote for Rob in this one, I may be wrong but the "spaceman" part of the stip is the jumps up to the top rope and he actually followed the stip where as Favian ran along the top rope, which I liked but you missed out a part of the stip.

Rob, I like your running alot and I like how you made Bourne climb the ropes. The corkscrew was great and you had the best reaction of all the people in this match. I didn't like how you could see string and I wasn't a big fan on how Bourne crouched before he jumped of the top rope Fave, your animation was great but as I said earlier, you didn't follow the stip. XBLKID, Your animation isn't bad but you could improve on your running and the stiffness in your animation.

yeah, ITS EDDIE

[[The Ukrainian One] Dimburuk]

Vote Ron ;D

Fave - wrong stip.

XBLkid - nice try man! it was pretty smooth, but had kinda bad joint movements, so it looked a bit stiff, also i saw some strings, and reaction could be better. But if you animate like that and do some improving i can clearly see you in title matches like this again and again

Rob - at the beginning Dolph moves were kinda fidgety a bit, nice taunt by Eddie, the running was really great, i really wonder how it always comes out so good. Nice climbing to the top rope, wasn't stiff, was smooth but missed only 1-2 frames i guess, the mid-air part should have used more pics too, but it wasn't as stiff as XBLkid, and i like the fall and reaction from both figs, looks cool. Editing.. worst part of your ani. But still, nice animation.

If Fave made the correct stip i guess he could won, but the stip was wrong. So, vote Ron

[wwestevo07]

Favian: The most creative ani. The running looked pretty good but still needed to be spaced out a little more but it was really smooth and wasn't stiff. The corkscrew was great but what i dont like about this ani and feel let it down was the way after the move they just froze then it just showed two different frames of them not moving then jericho then back to a reaction, would have looked a lot better if they reacted straight away then showed jericho after it.

XBLKID: Smooth for most parts. Nice try with the running but could have been a lot better, looked more like walking and needed to be faster. The jump onto the ropes didn't really work well, should have bent him a little before the jump. The corkscrew need a bit more air and was stiff.

Rob: Smooth throughout, i liked the build up at the start showing ziggler then a taunt by eddie. The running was smooth and looked great. I liked the corkscrew, looked great. I think you should have taken the blue tac off eddies feet in the corkscrew. I feel this had the best reaction out of all the animations.

Pretty close between Rob and Fave. Both pretty much matched but only thing i can decide it on is the reactions. In fave's the figs froze with two frames lasting a few seconds then they reacted which i feel doesn't work but in robs they reacted straight away and it looked a lot better.

Vote: Rob

[Ross]

Aug 13, 2012 10:55:02 GMT -5 wwextreme25 said:

Aug 13, 2012 6:57:54 GMT -5 Ross said:

I vote for Rob in this one, I may be wrong but the "spaceman" part of the stip is the jumps up to the top rope and he actually followed the stip where as Favian ran along the top rope, which I liked but you missed out a part of the stip.

Rob, I like your running alot and I like how you made Bourne climb the ropes. The corkscrew was great and you had the best reaction of all the people in this match. I didn't like how you could see string and I wasn't a big fan on how Bourne crouched before he jumped of the top rope Fave, your animation was great but as I said earlier, you didn't follow the stip. XBLKID, Your animation isn't bad but you could improve on your running and the stiffness in your animation.

yeah, ITS EDDIE

Sorry my bad though it was Bourne, dunno why.