THE A2O vs. WWEStevo07 vs. the Mexican Aristocrat, Myyqee.
How to vote on matches:
No polls and no suckish replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following:
1) State the username of the person you are voting for.
2) You must give reasons on why you have voted this person as the winner. Give at least a paragraph long reply (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended)
If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.
Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.
Post by kwaanimations on Jul 2, 2012 10:11:28 GMT -5
This will be hard to vote but ill try my best. Arrow- Move 1: The running into the move was nice and smooth and not fidgety. the spinning was good from the messiah but daniel bryan was stiff or needed more of a bend. the rest of the messiah through the flaming table was overall smooth and had great air time making it very realistic. the reaction was a bit unfinished as it needed more of a reaction. 8.5/10
Move:2 This one was better than the messiah on smoothness but not overall better. The build up was great and you took a lot of time on this other than the double foot stomp . going to the move, it was blurry with the pics making it distratcing and noticed string making it a bit more distracting. the move itself was very good, smooth,not fidgety and had good impact and reaction. I would give this a 9.5/10 but the distractions make it lower down. 8/10 Total: 16.5/20
Stevo- Move 1: This was not the average stevo. the running was as good as arrows, nothing wrong with it. the spinnig stuff was great as randy had a good pickup and reaction. The end was dissapointing, it needed more rope bounce, tyson suddenly froze and randy moved one picture and stayed the same fore the next like a pattern. 7/10
Move 2: Much better than move 1. this didnt require build up like arrows did so i wont say anything about that. this was very smooth, no blurry pics and I just cant find anything wrong with it. I liked the air time as it was suppose to be unrealistic. nothing wowing so 9.5/10 Total: 16.5/20 Myquee- Move 1: Your messiah was the best. First thing first is your first pic is way too long (not a big deal). the running was the usual. the spinnibg was very good but jomo could of used more of a reaction. I fell in love with the end of the messiah, impact and reaction. lots of bounces making the reaction greater.Your best so i'll give it a 9.5/10 but make the first pic maybe 1.00 Move 2: this was pretty good. the springboard off the jump was good like stevos with great air time. going through the table jomo looked like he broke his neck making the end of the move a fail. chavo froze leavin jomo the only one with a reatcion and needed more of a rope bounce. dissapointing 7.5/10 17/20
Arrow Animation 1- the running wasn't that good I recommend don't extend the legs as much any more the move overall was pretty stiff I loved the fire and it was a good reaction also it's the world title match edit all the wires out overall 9 out of 10
Animation 2- the black lines(wires) were really distracting on this one I like the build up and the move itself was great I personally thought yoshi should of grabbed his leg for a pin b/c there wasn't a reaction 8.5 out of 10.
Overall 17.5 out of 20
Animation 1- loved this the reaction was magnificent the move itself could of been faster the running was alright 9.5 out of 10
Animation 2- the height was perfect the move itself was flawless the reaction was great 10 out of 10
Overall 19.5 out of 20
Animation 1- this was perfect just a tad blurry but move was at a perfect speed perfect running and the move and reaction was just great 10 out of 10
Animation 2- not your best the rope spring was good chavos way to jomo looked weird and th way sown was choppy but with a good reaction 8 out of 10
Stevo. His messiah completely won me over. It was the smoothest and the most realistic. Arrows was a bit floaty. Myqee's was good i just thought Stevo had the better reactions and such. As for the other animation. I thought stevos had the greatest flow and seen no string. It was just absolutely phenomenal.
Post by wwextreme25 on Jul 2, 2012 15:22:30 GMT -5
Messiah: Looked nice. Why you have te ropes off i dont know. I liked the running and bryans movements. The main thing that bugged me was whilst yoshi was madly circling around bryan, bryan stood almost still and didnt look like he was panicking at all. It all looked unrealistic how bryan just casually move his arms without much movement whilst yoshi was circling rapidly around him. however once yoshi got bryan into the rko position thing, it looked really nice and flowed well. Somewhat stiff in the legs however it was a great effort. 8.8/10
springboard, Corkscrew huricanrana: Dont get the starship pain, bit of uneeded build up tbh. So imm just comment on the STIP itself not the build up. The way yoshi turned over and slid under the ropes was a bit weird and fidgety. I liked the springboard, it flowed nicely but i saw 1/2 blurry pics. Also the corkscrew was extremely floaty and looked a little weird in the movements and seemed a few pics were missing maybe. Huricanrana was ok but the legs on jomo were really really stiff and it just wasnt as good as it couldve been. 8.1/10
Messiah: Really nice job on this. Ortons movements were incredibly realistic and i thought they flowed awesomely. I liked tyson's back step to get leverage off the ropes And then the lift up was superbly done. When tyson was manoeuvring around orton, both tyson and orton's movements were really really good. Unlike arrow, you had orton (he had bryan) move and flare his joints more as tyson (he had yoshi) moved around him and it made it look more realistic. Also i thought your animation had an overall better speed and consistent flow which i like Tyson was a little stiff when falling to the mat but overall, thats all i can see wrong, i liked the reactions and everything looked really nice good job. 9/10
springboard, Corkscrew huricanrana: really loved sheamus' movements in this before tyson actually hit the move looked really realistic and i just thought, as a whole, it was amazing. Tyson was kinda stiff in the springboard so maybe flare some legs a little instead of having them stayed together but i liked the arm movement. Coming off the springboard i thought tyson landed the corkscrew perfectly and had great mid air movements, however when he landed on sheamus, maybe sheamus shouldve bended his knees a bit more to show tyson is heavy and e's getting balance. I loved the Huricanrana though. Both movements were incredible from both figures and the impact was great. great job 8.9/10
Messiah: Morrison's, movements throughout the animation was really good. I loved the way he wasnt fidgety throughout and it looked nice and realistic. Chavo's running was incredible and i loved the way he paused, mid way through the movements around morrison, to gather up a lot of momentum into the impact, looked effective. I think on imapct, you shouldve had both figure up in the air instead of morrison leaving a foot on the ground, it wouldve added much more impact. however it was really nicely animated as it flowed really well and had hardly any flaws. maybe add a bit more rope bounce and it wouldve been perfect. good job, 9/10
springboard, Corkscrew huricanrana: Morrison started out a little bit fidgety whilst he was on the table. I liked the lift in the springboard but as soon as chavo hit the ropes, he became very fidgety and it looked odd. The corkscrew itself was amazing imo. Flowed really nice and the movement from chavo was great. Its the huricanrana which let you down. It started off nice but then it went incredibly choppy, maybe because you ad to delete some frames i dunno, but it was really choppy and ruined the whole animation form. really nice job but i just think that this couldve been so much better with a better reaction and more frames in the 'rana but good job overall. 8/10
Animation Profile: 1x World Heavyweight Champion
2x High Flyers Champion (Longest Reigning)
1x Entrance King Champion (Longest Reigning)
3x Slammy Award Winner
1x Money in the bank winner
Cam Messiah: This was defiantly the most accurate messiah out of all of them. The movements where just right. it was also a good animation, making it the best overall animation of the match. Bryan fidgeted a bit at the beginning and i don't know why he was standing almost directly over the flames there was a bit of noob blurr during the running. The messiah was great but bryan was a little stiff. Nice table break and nice reaction.
other thing: Didn't look very realistic. the pauses where slightly to long. saw bits of string here an there.
stevo messiah- Don't know why tyson sorta fidgeted his hands around in the beginning, didn't like that, just seemed weird. The Rko part has stiff as they where falling down. really nice impact. Orton also seemed a tiny bit fidgety at the end as he was turning over and i didn't like the random head movement at the end.
other move: this was defiantly the best version of this move in the entire match. Love tysons jump from the rope, but he never really unbent his legs, it still looked good but kinda weird and slightly stiff. the rest of the move was spot. the reaction was a little slow though, made it look kind of choppy.
This is really hard to vote on because Cam made the best messiah and stevo made the best springboard hurricanrahna thing. They where pretty much equal but Cams Springboard thing was closer to the status of stevos springboard than stevos messiah was to cams messiah.
Arrow : Messiah - Very nice animation... it was smooth and creative with the fire... my only problem was the flips of the messiah was unrealistic and d-bry was a bit stiff... I loved the reaction though. Other Animation - I like the effort you placed into your build up... the animation itself was smooth...JoMo wasn't reactive during the flips and the reaction was stiff
Stevo : Great animation! It was the smoothest with the least amount of stiffness... I loved the running and the speed... the reaction was great and had the best realistic feel. Other Animation : Amazing! It was smooth, realistic, not stiff... my only problem was the reaction was a bit dull.
Myyqee : Messiah - Great animation! It was smooth, not fidgety like your past animations, with a fantastic reaction... my only flaws was that it was blurry and JoMo was a bit stiff during the move. Other Animation - Good Animation... it was smooth with a good reaction... it was just very fidgety... which really ruined the animation
Vote : Stevo
WFigs Animating Record : 7 - 18 WFigs Pivot Record : 6 - 3
NEW-COMER OF 2012! 1x Tag Team Champion (w/ HOF Ross!) 1x UltraViolent Champion 2x (Pivot) Tag Team Champion
Post by Scottanized on Jul 2, 2012 19:06:54 GMT -5
Arrow: The fire was a nice edtion as was the running. The running was pretty good but seemed a little slow. The whole messiah was great and neither figure was stiff mid air. My only complaint is that the figures were stiff while falling down. The impact and reaction was nice though. The build up was uneeded so Im going to skip that. Jomo was a tiny bit stiff while yoshi was jumping on the ropes, Yoshi had nice moves on the ropes and wasn't stiff. The flippy part was really nice and not stiff aswell. There was a nice reaction aswell. My only complaint is a few blurry pictures and the stiffness of the pop.
Stevo: Orton wasn't stiff throughout the running and messiah, Its incredibly smooth, but its really slow where it looks unrealistic. And like cams the figure are stiff while falling. It has a nice impact but after there isn't much of a reaction. Sheamoose wasn't that stiff during the jump up of tyson. Tyson though was stiff. The move was incredibly smooth like the messiah but tyson was stiff mid air and his arms looked a bit fidgety. There wasn't much of a reaction either and it looks strange how he ended up on top of Tyson.
Myyqee: During the running and messiah Jomo was very stiff. Chavos reaction was a bit stiff and fidgety. Jomo had a great reaction though. The moth was mostly smooth but some parts were fidgety. Jomo was fidgety in the beginning and his movements were random and unrealistic. Chavo had good movements though but was fidgety mid air. He was a bit stiff but not that much :3 His flight pattern though was somewhat unrealistic though. The pop was stiff as well and needed more pics. The reaction was very fast and fidgety finally.
I usually never vote in Arrows matches to prevent people from calling me bias, but since this is a WHC match and I believe his animations are better and votes are more important I'll vote. I can't believe I'm saying this, but I'm going to have to vote arrow. Unlike Stevo, Arrow made the messiah correctly and it was better executed than Myyqees. All the pops were stiff midair so it went down to the jumps and reactions which both Arrow was better in.
Since this is so close, im going to include ratings for each animation so the best person truely wins.
Arrow: The inclusion of a flaming table was nice, but somewhat random for a move like this. I feel like you added it just to increase the amount of votes you will get. Regardless, the flames do look nice, and the table does make your animation look good. The running was great, but I feel the left arm should have gone forward with the right leg, and vise versa. The run and jump were smooth, but I didnt like how effortlessly Yoshi jumped into Bryans arms. Ive studied this move quite a bit on youtube to watch for details, and in the real move their is a lot of effort put by the opponent to swing the wreslter up and around to actually make this move possible. Bryan just stood there for most of the move as Yoshi floated around. Bryan should have also started falling during the end of the swing to make the move look more realistic. The fall and table break were good, and the reaction was okay. Overall this animation was very smooth and had a good speed. 8/10
Your second one was just as good, the taunt and jump looked very smooth and yoshi had good movement too. Yoshi moving out of the way was smooth but it looked weird how he sat up. The starship pain was done very well, maybe John could have gotten a little more height but it looked great nonetheless. The impact was great and Johns movements afterwords were good aswell. Yoshis west coast pop looked awesome, the way it looked like a piledriver was a positive and negative to me, so it balenced out. Yoshis reaction was good but I wasnt a fan of Morrisons arm movement. I still really liked this ani though. 8.5/10
Stevo, I thought your Messiah was great. The backup and run looked good and what really set yours apart from Arrows was the movement during the move. I felt like it almost perfectly replicated what the move looks like and the fall looked great. I feel like Tysons legs were a little stiff but thats pretty much how the move is. The impact and reaction were great, and they were only a little slow. Tyson kinda froze at the end, but its minor. 9/10
Other move was good too, Kidd and Sheamus started off good but Kidds jump was stiff. The airtime was great, and I like the firmness of the landing. The flip looks like it was sped up a bit and I like that. The landing was more real looking than Arrows, but Arrows had a better impact. The reactions were good for a knocked down and tired feel, maybe they should have had a bit more room to move instead of on top of each other. But I really like this one. 9/10
Myyqee, your Messiah was good too, but my least favorite of the bunch. The run(or step) was good but it suffered from the lack of opponent movement that Arrows had untill the end where you had Morrison fall. That I did like. Yours seemed a little more floaty though and the turned landing looked weird. I love the impact though and Morrisons reaction is good. Chavos reaction looked a little slidy but overal it was a good animation. 7/10
Your second move had a unique setting. I like the opening movements and the jump and despite the unrealism, you made the move flow very nicely which always can make up for that. It was very smooth and the hurricarana was nice. My only complaint was that Chavo shouldn`t have grabbed Morrisons legs during the fall, it made it look kinda weird. The table break, impact, and reaction were all great and I love the ani overall. 8/10