How to vote on matches: No polls and no suckish replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following:
1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?)
2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended)
If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.
Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.
Post by wwextreme25 on Feb 26, 2012 15:53:19 GMT -5
and for me, this came down to dimburuk and josh...
josh - nice entrance, but itwas stiff in the powerbomb and had fidgety elements in there. No effects which is what makes the entrance king division but good effort. Just seemed too, boring for my liking sorry :/
dima - fireworks were awesome, titantron didnt go on for too long and nice greenscreen effects. I think the way you had kane turn round only to find batista waiting for him was cool. the spear was nice but a tad stiff but that can be worked on so good effort overall - work on stiffness
overall i think dima gets my vote - well done to the rest of you
Animation Profile: 1x World Heavyweight Champion
2x High Flyers Champion (Longest Reigning)
1x Entrance King Champion (Longest Reigning)
3x Slammy Award Winner
1x Money in the bank winner
My vote stills the same, this came down to Dimburuk, Jack & Josh, but I vote for Dimburuk.
His entrance had each component an entrance should have : Pyro effects, Green Screen, Titantron, music, crowd etc. while in others' (besides Bryan), It didn't have any of this (besides music). Kane's walking was decent - Sure it's not the best out of all of these, but it was nice, mostly, followed by the Spear. The spear itself looked quite good, and realistic, but you should've worked on holding Batista's legs a slightly up and on bending the figures joints a bit more. It wasn't that stiff, but stiffness was noticeable. Your ani was a tiny choppy and blurry, and I think that it's due to Vegas. However, it wasn't as choppy as Josh's. Jack had a brillant entrance. It was really good and stuff, but if he only added effects, and deleted that fade out before Undertaker's Suicide Dive, I would've voted for you. I liked Josh's entrance aswell, but I think, It needed more frames, working more on stiffness and on editing. Asmi did a nice work as well, but it didn't had effects, I saw strings, and camera was shaking. Good luck guys.
Post by /X Metal Sorenges x "Mac Oh J~ on Feb 26, 2012 19:36:24 GMT -5
My vote goes to Nico because he was the only one who followed the stipulation or Josh for modified stipulation ani
The Bryan: The greenscreen looked good, the entrance was nice. When Tommy hit Alberto in the back with the garbage can, it looked a bit choppy and fast also you forgot to finish the stipulation.
CarltonFan2010/Josh: The entrance was good, I like how you switched angles from the attackers point of view, the clothesline was smooth but a bit slow on the fall and the string was visible. The powerbomb into the table was smooth but Kevin could have elevated Cena more before the drop to add more realism to the ani. The impact was nice, but you could have extended the animation a little longer.
Dimburuk: The pyro at the beginning was amazing and looking very realistic. The titration was good. When Kane came out it looked a bit to fast. The spear at the end was smooth and not very stiff.
Nico: The entrance was really good, I like how it was dark then Jericho appear afterwords. The pyrotechnics wasn't very well made. The walking was a little stiff, the garbage can hit was nice. After that when he placed the garbage can on the the ground the animation looked a little to fast.
The Only Jack of Jacks: The entrance of CM Punk at the beginning was good, I don't like how it pauses momentarily goes dark then goes onto the next scene. It somewhat ruined the flow of the animation during it. Undertaker's running was smooth and the jump was also smooth, the impact was lacking a bit though.
Roccastar28: Mainly the entire animation was fast, shaky and choppy. Bret Hart entrance was ok, your hand was in some of the frames, the spin was nice, but it was a bit fidgety. When Batista hit him in the back it was really smooth, the powerbomb itself however was very choppy and fast.
Asni5065: The shaking of the camera at the beginning, didn't seem to flow well with the entrance theme, The titration was good, but Big Show looked a little stiff and slow walking. The chair shot looked a little choppy and incomplete.
Was variation allow in this match? if so I'll edit my vote with who I believe did the best. Still not sure what type of stipulation can be performed in this match but I'll let Dutt decide which one.