No polls and no suckish replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following:
1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?)
2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended)
If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.
Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.
Post by wwextreme25 on Jan 28, 2012 14:54:20 GMT -5
nidz and zack -
nidz - wasnt bad, smooth and ran smoothly however it was very stiff and fidgety which ruined it. It wasnt all that bad until the wierd camera movement at the end. Not bad but, a bit wierd - 7/10
zack - not bad, i liked the teamwork between london and punk before the move - almost some communication as if to say *lift me up* but punk was stiff throughout, the whole ani was choppy and fidgety but i did like the impact. good effort but not your best. 6.9/10
TheScottStopmotion ;D -
scott - nice move...the movements were jws standard..the main thing killing it-for me- was the string. The joints were moved brilliantly and you are becoming better than you ever were, imo. not stiff...VERY smooth, and one of your best anis - only if you edited string D; but well done. 9/10
wes-not your best, unfortunately. I liked it, it flowed well, however it looked as though punk put no effort in at all to lift orton - orton just flew up automatically. Impact was nice, the whole thing was sorta slow but nonetheless a good effot. 7/10
Animation Profile: 1x World Heavyweight Champion
2x High Flyers Champion (Longest Reigning)
1x Entrance King Champion (Longest Reigning)
3x Slammy Award Winner
1x Money in the bank winner
Wes, that was too shaky. Not your best, light changed.. It had enough pictures but... Too shaky D: Scott- That was smooth, I liked the leg movement of Eddie. Saw string, Chavo was smooth, good rope bounce.. team point- 16/20
Nidz- too slow and stiff, I saw string. the rope bounce was good, I didn't like the zoom in effect that much x.x
Zack- Saw blurry pics, I like the taunts at the beggining. The string editing was rough. Nice reaction.
overall team score- 14/20
Last Edit: Jan 28, 2012 15:00:36 GMT -5 by Deleted
Wes- It was okay, nice movements actually, the main part I didn't like was the camera angle change throughout the animation, makes it seem abit choppy but nonetheless good animation, also work on impact and reactions bro. Babe- Smoothest ani of all in this match. Not that stiff expect for when Eddie was about to hit impact on Truth, and impact and reaction was meh, plus Chavo slid like a skater. :3
Nidz- Kinda smooth but slow at the beginning, stiff, saw string, the zoom in didn't help the ani at all, finally impact and reaction wasn't all that good. :/ Zack- Smooth, abit stiff for London with his Wesly gorilla arms, nice airtime, good impact, but reaction wasn't that good. :X
Vote: The Scott and Screamo Guy
Why you ask? Their anis just flowed all around better than Nidz and Zack and was less stiff. :3
Post by [The Ukrainian One] Dimburuk on Jan 28, 2012 15:10:03 GMT -5
Wes : it was smooth, only a lil bit stiff, i liked how Punk threw Orton and how Punk turned after throwin Viper. Air time was nice, flowed pretty good. No string saw. Reaction from Zigler needs to be a lil bigger. Awesome ani.
Scott : it was smooth, R Truth moving was nice touch, i saw string, ani was not stiff, but, i think that Chavo should throw Eddie more, because it looked like Eddie just fell down(or maybe you just need to speed up a bit). Reaction was nice.
Nidz : veeeeryyyyy stiff and slow.. :x nothing much to say
Zack : a bit choppy, not stiff, like that Flair was movinsg, nice reaction, saw string.. not your best.
Vote : Scott and Wes
Animation achievements :
1. First ever Intercontinental Champion in history
2. Beginners champion[2x]
3. Hosted a PPV
Wes- Not bad, the lift was kinda smooth but the backflip was choppy and the camera pan upwards was weird, the lighting flashed a bit as well which was kind of annoying. I loved the reaction/impact though. 7/10
Scoot- I liked the lift, it was very smooth bit i didn't like how Eddie spread his legs so fast. It looked awkward and unbalanced. The backflip was smooth and the impact was nice but the reactions were meh. 8.5/10 Next time don't use black guys on a black ring mat..couldn't tell wtf he was doing :3
Nigz- Lift was smooth but stiff and fidgety, backflip was also smooth but stiff as well and i didn't like how the camera zoomed inwards, guess you were trying to do the added impact effect like Blake does? anyways those should be done in Sony Vegas not manually as they don't turn out well. Reaction was bleh. 6/10
Zack- Not one of your best, it was pretty choppy in the lift and moonsault. Lighting wasn't that great but i like how you had Flair(?) moving the whole time, Impact was nice yet weird...bounce could have used more pics. 5/10
wes: it was a bit too shaky but the moonsault looks smooth. but you must try to make better impacts and your anis will looking much better overall: 8/10
scott: very smooth, liked the lift up and nice reaction. chavos joints were moved perfectly and i saw string overall: 8,5/10
nidz: the animation was sometimes smooth but mostly stiff. the lift up and the moonsault looking good aswell but that at the end was useless. without that it would be better overall: 5/10
zack: the moonsault was too fast and punk a bit too stiff :/ the animation overall is not that good and i think that you can animate better than this. the reaction was ... good. still nice overall: 6/10
Wes: Great ani! It was pretty smooth even though it lacked some pics in the first part, it wasn't stiff, the reaction was good, saw no string, shadows or hands. I didn't like the camera angle and how it changed though.
Scott: Very smooth, the smoothest out of them all, not stiff, good camera angle, saw a lot of string, but the thing that kills the animation is the missing reaction.
Nidz: Good animation, it would have been smooth if it wasn't that slow, speed it up, it will look really good, I don't know what happened during the impact and reaction but the changing zoom is really distracting. Keep practicing and you will improve.
Zack: not up to your usual standards, the camera angle ruined it cause it seemed choppy even though it was smooth. Impact was good, reaction was okay.
Vote: Wes and Scott In total Wes and Scott just had the better animations all around. But Nidz and Zack you will improve if you keep practicing
Wescott: I`ll comment on Wes` first, the animation seemed choppy, I dont understand why you use such a slow pace for some of your animations, wasn't stiff tbh, but the shakyness of the camera really annoyed me, still good. Now onto Scott`s animation, really smooth animation, not stiff at all, which is a HUGE improvement, main flaw was the string.
nigzack: nigs` animation was smooth, but really fidgety, string was really annoying, and the zoom in was really weird, the shaky camera too was annoying. Onto Zack`s animation, seemed quite choppy, needed more pictures or speeding up, you too suffer from shaky camera syndrome Not one of your best Zack...
Guys, I know these anis for these matches arent my best, I tried my best and.. I just, cant get my animations to look good again, I just dont know why(if someone had the same problem before, please help me to get back my older animations, animating is my life). So, Since I didnt win the HF contenders and the Tag Team contenders, I decided to stop animating for this forum for next/next 2 ppv and start animating for my fed..
11-0-21 in ppvs 7-1-4 in single matches Former HF title for 41 days!(August 2nd till September 11) Main evented Halloween Havoc II! But didnt win the WHC. Was apart of two main events on Survivor Series(WHC and 5v5). But didnt win the WHC and lost to Team Rob on 5v5. 1x Slammy Award Winner! The holder of the tag team titles briefcase 8)
Post by /X Metal Sorenges x "Mac Oh J~ on Jan 30, 2012 19:57:29 GMT -5
I say Scott and Wes won this one.
✖Scott[V]ersion2✖ and Wes: Good job on this one guys the animations were pretty good except Wes during the flip looked only a bit stiff and could be sped up and Scott seemed a bit to fast. The impact and reactions of both were decent however and the assist of both ani's were smooth. 7.8/10
Zack and Nidz: Not bad guys still needs a little bit of work but it was a great attempt. Overall both animations were ok, Zack's animation Paul flip looked way to fast during air time and string was visible, both CM Punk's hands and feet look really stiff throughout the animation, I didn't like how Paul had a bouncing reaction due to the lack of impact need for the move and the sudden camera angle somewhat ruined your ani.
Nidz ani was alright, the lift was smooth but it was choppy and stiff during air time, the string was visible throughout the entire animation and the effect at the end really ruined the animation unfortunately. 5.7/10