WF: Christmas Chaos Match #1

[Deleted]

Hello and welcome to Christmas Chaos!



WF MITB Round #2

Stip:
~Create a High flying move off a ladder

Match 5: Rob vs Josh

Match 6: Arrow vs Scotty

Match 5:
Rob



Josh

i1177.photobucket.com/albums/x354/carltonfan2010/ani2-1.gif

Match 6:
Arrow



Scotty

i1199.photobucket.com/albums/aa466/stingchristianrko2/SCPTTSSP.gif

How to vote on matches:

No polls and no suckish replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following:

1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?)

2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended)

If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.

Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.

*Voting ends in 24 hours

[Deleted]

*MITB ROUND 3 WILL BE AN AFTERSHOW DARK MATCH ;D *

[Deleted]

Rob: Wow, absolutely stunning. Your animation was smooth, not stiff and flowed really well. The impact was okay, had a good reaction. I just can´t believe how much you´ve improved. You could go toe to toe with the best of them with something like this. The only thing I didn´t like that much was the first turn, I feel like it took to long and was too late, and that his feet got to close too his victim before he flipped onto his stomach at the end. I notice a lot of animators put the feet too close before flipping onto their stomach.

Josh: Shawn had no buildup or jump imo. I noticed you added Triple H moving the ladder, but after he let it go it kept moving. Shawn was a little stiff, and I noticed that he actually would of overshot the jump. He just stopped immediately in one spot, Thatś the thing that really bugs me. And he sped up just before Shawn hit the victim. But the table break was nice. Not your best though.

Vote: Rob.

Arrow: Very well done here, I liked the jump. It was the right speed and flowed well, but why are you back to your spring ring? It really held you back in this one. Because he had no room to jump to and almost botched and hit the ladder. The impact was good, but it would of been better if London sprung up off it. The reaction was pretty good. A little stiff.

Scott: It looked floaty, wasn´t the right speed. If you sped it up it would of been a lot better. However the jump was good and I loved how he moved his legs in the air, made it look good and it had a really good impact. Loved the reaction too. But Arrow just slides through this one imo.

Vote: Arrow.

[Scotty]

it was .06 it cant go any faster

[Wes.]

My vote goes to Scott. His was smooth, and had a very slightly better reaction than Arrow's.
Josh's...well...HBK was moving foward then moved back, unrealistically for the landing. That was the only big flaw with it. Rob, the beginning taunt on yours was fantastic, but the rest was floaty and fidgety :/
Good job by everyone.

[wwextreme25]

so who you voting for with me and carlton?
theres two matches here...

[Zack]

Wow two great matches,I wished I am in this one though.

Match 1:

Josh,first of all,great job. I like how you added HHH there to hold the ladder.before the move,You should have added a little more jump and a taunt before the move to make it more realistic.The splash was VERY unrealistic,sorry man. I mean Hbk already overhit the splash,but he surprisingly moved back and in time to hit the splash O.o But the splash was very smooth and it flows very nicely. Love the table break and the taunt by HHH too. But one thing that kind of ruined the ani was the ladder. The ladder moved a lot in this ani,you should try using blu tack or some tape to hold it on...But great Job Josh,6/10.

Rob,once again,great job. The move,once again,needed more jump,I like the taunt though. The flaming star itself was great,there's nothing really to comment about the flaming star.The reaction was great but I understand you cant move the arms of Jeff Hardy's opponent. The lighting changed a bit but it didnt change the animation much. There's really nothing to say,great job Rob 8/10

Vote goes to.....Rob! Sorry Josh,work harder

Match 2:

Scott,great job,One of your best. Love the taunt at the start. The squad is great too. The jump was great and the ssp was very smooth. I liked how you moved Sandman too. Not stiff at all and I love the table break. But,I saw a lot of strings. You should have edited them out next time if some was shown. Sandman's reaction was bad but Paul London's was great,you could have made Paul London to hold his body tho. great job man,one of your best,nothing really to say,8/10!

Arrow,first of all,great job,you improved a lot this year. Loved the taunt,jump was great and it was very smooth. Great air time on the ssp and I like how Curt Hawkins moved throughout the ssp. Reaction was great too.There's really no flaw in this animation other than Paul London being a little stiff,great job man,9.5/10

My vote goes to Arrow! Sorry Scotty,you improved a lot but Arrow is just a little better than you,great job both of you!

[[The Ukrainian One] Dimburuk]

A-ma-zing matches, guys!

Rob vs Josh :

Rob - your was absolutely amazing! I really liked the taunt at the beginning, i liked how Edge(?) was moving on the ground, i didn't see string, animation was very good, not even stiff! Looked realistic! Amazing!

Josh - i really liked it! It is very smooth, not stiff. I really liked the jump and the mid-air time, looks awesome! Table break and rope bounce look awesome! The problem is, like W said, looks like Shawn went too far, so he just falled down, without moving forward. It was a bit stiff in the end.

Vote : Rob

Arrow vs Scotty

Arrow - very smooth, not stiff, i liked the taunt. But, it looks like London went for flip too fast, but great string work! Reaction was very good!

Scotty - same smooth as Arrow, even a bit smoother, i liked the taunt, jump looks nice, a bit slow before the move connected, but not really. It was not stiff, i like how Sandman was moving. Nice reaction, nice string work, not stiff!

Vote : Scotty

[wweanimation09]

First Match - Vote : Rob

Reason: Rob yours was great, smooth and awesome air time. Josh HBK went forwards and floated backwards, IMO you should have re-done the animation.

Second Match - Vote - Scotteh

Reason - Arrow you animation was choppy in mid air and no where near what i expected. Scott yours was very smooth but it needed more of a reaction. Arrow yours had good impact but also lacked a decent reaction.

[0,Y]

Match 5

Vote: Rob
both were smooth, main problem in Joshs animation was: Shawn jumped too far and then somehow back in the direction of the ladder. And Rob decided to animate a more difficult move.
Good match here.

Match 6

Vote: Scotteh
Both were smooth, Scottys was even a bit smoother. Both had non-distracting string. Arrows had a bad impact in my opinion (spring ring problem), reactions were decent.
I like how every figure in both animations were moving around.

[Adam]

Match 1
WWExtreme25- good taunt smooth animation not stiff. when he went to do the move he bent down and didnt come back up he just flew. good air time. reaction was okay could have been better. good ani

Carlton- i like how you had triple h holding the ladder but it ended up looking like he was trying to move it. The main problem for me in the animation is that shawn went forward past the table then quickly flew back. but the table break was good and the animation was smooth.

Vote - WWExtreme25

Match 2

Arrow- good taunt could have been more of a jump. it was smooth and the air time was great. i think the impact looked pretty good and the reaction was okay but realistic. no shadows but a little bit of string.

Scotteh- the taunt was pretty good. the jump was great but when in the air it was slow. very smooth. no shadows but i saw a lot of string. the table break was great. reaction could of been a little bigger.
very close match guys
vote- Arrow

[Deleted]

*VOTING IS OVER*

Need tiebreaker for Scotty/Arrow

[Deleted]

Match one:

Robs was extremely smooth, hes gettin really good with that lately. The problem here is Hardy barley jumped, and when doing a move like that you need plenty of height to avoid floatyness, which is exactly what he had. The rotation and flip were great, if it wasnt so floaty this animation would be amazing. Regardless, the impact and reaction were great and the animation overall was extremely smooth(yes i know i mentioned that). I dont like how Josh`s goes straight into the move without any jumping movements. The animation itself was smooth though, which I would expect from a splash. Shawns midair direction changed which kinda bugged me. I also didnt like how the ladder moved even though hunter was holding it. The table break was nice and Triple H`s reaction was good too. Woulda been nice to see Shawn move though.

VOTE: ROB




Match2:
Arrows also been gettin better lately, another smooth ani here and the taunt before the move was good. Pauls jump was good and even though he didnt get much height the move looked very realistic. Hawkins before move movements were nice but the after move reaction was meh. Scoot started off with a similar taunt, just as smooth. I didnt like the jump as much as arrows though. But he moved the arms more in his which was a nice touch. I did notice a little bit of fidgettyness though, and string was an eyesore. The impact and reaction looked a little weird.

I think if Scoot edited his string it woulda made it a tie but..

VOTE: ARROW

[Deleted]

Dec 21, 2011 20:02:03 GMT -5 @carltonfan2010 said:

*VOTING IS OVER* WINNER IS Rob/Arrow*

PISS

[Deleted]

Dec 21, 2011 20:07:08 GMT -5 @carltonfan2010 said:

Angus, your vote counts, its Arrow and Rob going to the MITB final round...

oh....
;D

[Deleted]

I thought it was Arrow vs Rob, not Scotty vs Rob in the final ._.