No polls and no suckish replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following:
1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?)
2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended)
If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.
Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.
*Voting ends in 48 hours
Last Edit: Jan 21, 2011 18:43:33 GMT -5 by Deleted
Post by stopmotionguy01 on Jan 16, 2011 13:48:11 GMT -5
My vote goes to LKANGUS. There animations were smoother, liked both of them. saw no string, weren't choppy or stiff. Absolutely amazing animations. lks, that was my favorite animation of the ppv so far. 9.5/10
My vote goes to................NGA. Before you guys think I'm crazy, Ima give you the reasons why I'm voting for NGA. First of all, LKS made the wrong kind of piledriver. Now don't get me wrong, it was a spectacular ani, but it was supposed to be a package piledriver, which means you lift the guys arms up aswell. On to NGA, Scotty, your ani was smooth but a tad bit fidgety. And Arrow, decent ani, not your best but it was also smooth and had that taunt at the end, so pretty nice touch to the ani. There, you guys see where I'm coming from. Btw, Angus, f*ckin nice ani, and good table break. But LKS making the wrong move ruined it for me.
Even though LKS failed to do the stip that was asked . . .It was a really good animation. loved the way Edge walked onto the steps. Really nice touch. Angus. . his animation was smooth, saw no string, Very good.
Post by Jesseversion1 on Jan 16, 2011 18:18:56 GMT -5
LKAngus: Both of your guyes animation were awesome. LKS yours was the best out of all 4. I really like it, from the taunt to the running up the steps to the end i thought was perfect! Angus your ani was always really good. The lift up was great then the drop was good but the table break seemed abit slow. And the reactions were slow. But i think its just my computer that makes it look slow.
NGA: You didnt really have a chance against LKAngus but you put up a good fight! Scott, your improving with every animation. The lift up was ok. You needed to have a little more of a jump. Impact and reactions really lacked. Also if you gonna do rope bounce you need to make the ropes bounce alot longer. Arrow, i really didnt like this one.. Mostly cause you started it with the guy already lifted up into the air. It was smooth. I didnt find it chopy or anything. I also didnt like how both of the figs went down(Fell) It didnt really look like a wrestling move it just kinda looked like he fell and droped him. Impact and reactions needed more work.
Better luck next time NGA! Good animations & Match
My vote goes to Team LkAngus: Both animations were smooth, realistic, no stiff, nice string edition. I really like the "iMPACT!" of the piledriver of LKS and the table breake of the brainbuster of Angus. Awesome team
NGA: Nice anis but both are not smooth enough. The animation of arrow was incomplete and I don't really like the reaction and the ani of Scott was great, The piledriver was awesome and I really like the reaction of Paul London but the camera was a little bit shaky.
Post by mrrocky619 on Jan 18, 2011 19:21:19 GMT -5
well this match is gonna be hard to vote on...
LKS: very good ani and i liked it a lot but you didn't follow the stip so there isn't much else i can say... since imma gonna be deciding the winner of this match based on points im just gonna dock like 5 points out of your final score. the beginning when he lifted his arm up was slightly stiff. and it seemed to me the camera was moving a tiny tiny bit throughout the ani. Christians' legs were also stiff as edge was walking up the steps. but the lighting was good, it was very smooth, and i didn't see string but the reaction could have been a little bit better. overall: 8/10 - 5 = 3/10 :/ the ani was incredible but the stip wasnt followed so i had to dock points ...
Angusto: The whole ani was a tiny bit fidgety. and i thought it went a little bit fast. the guys legs were a little bit stiff while he was upside down imo. i saw string in like one frame. the reaction was good, i liked how he grabbed his head. but punks reaction wasnt to great, while he was turning over to look at the other guy (christian?) he paused a few times and that made it look kinda weird. overall it was a very nice animation and maybe just try and work on fidgetyness a little bit, but it was only ever so slightly fidgety that it really doesnt matter. 7.5/10
Scotty: Camera was quite shaky. didnt really like how tommy just paused after raising his arm, it wouldve been fine if the camera wasnt so shaky, but... ya. it was as smooth as the rest but he did actually make the move right. it was a little bit fidgety, and there couldve been more of a reaction. I dont like it when the guys arent completely compressed on the ground... ya know what i mean... guys rarely have the neck muscles to hold themselves up like that... overall: 6.5/10
ARROW: would have liked to see paul lifting up Jericho rather than the ani just starting instantly from an already lifted position, and chris couldve at least been moving his legs a little bit while he was upside down. i saw some string (or shadows of string?). also it liked like a few frames or something were black or darker than the rest, idk about this but it sorta looked like the ani was flashing black ever so slightly?? it was a little stiff and the reaction couldve been better, like chris couldve held his head or something. defiantly not ur best but it was still decent, probably would have a lot higher score if you would've shown the lift up. overall: 7/10
so 6.5 + 7 = 13.5/20 and that is NGA's score
and 7.5 + 3 = 10.5/20 and that is LKAngus's score
sooo, if LKS wouldve made the correct move i think they most likely would have won this, buuut... he didnt. so my vote goes to "The most childish team EVER... No Girls Allowed, oh wait... New Generation animators..." when i was a wittle boy i had a club called the NGA and it stood for "no girls allowed"... but ya... good job everyone