No polls and no suckish replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following:
1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?)
2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended)
If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.
Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.
Post by wweuniverse47871 on Jan 15, 2011 9:58:02 GMT -5
This is a hard match. So I'll just leave a response on every ani then add em up and decide a winner.
Wes: Not your best ani. It was kinda slow and floaty. It didn't look stiff, but it absolutely no reaction really. Just a roll of and sit up that last half a second maybe. The camera was kinda shakey, but you don't really notice it that much. It had an alright impact, but it wasn't great. Not your best animation.... Overall Rating: 5/10
TTF4EVA: Probably the best animation there. It was smooth and looked very realistic. The splash part in the jump was kinda choppy but still kinda smooth at the same time. It happened very quickly.. There was great impact and a preety good reaction. Keep up the good work Overall Rating:8/10
Weston Overall Score: 13/20
Mitch: The best animation on your team. it was very smooth and looked awesome. The thing I didn't like in your ani was how the camera angle changed like 3 or 4 times, but I understand why it change, so you could see the animation. The impact and reaction were very good. You and ttf's animations were amazing and both of them we preety much equally good, but I like his a little more. Overall rating:7.5/10
Arrow: Not your best animation. It was smooth at the beginning then at the end it seemed a little bit choppy and went all stiff. The reaction wasn't the best but it was alright. The starting of the animation was the best part as it was the smoothest. Just take a lil more tie with the ani's and don't forget to move the joints and stuff Overall Rating: 6/10
Post by stopmotionguy01 on Jan 15, 2011 10:12:04 GMT -5
My vote goes to NGA. The moonsault was amazing. No flaws except maybe a little bit slow getting to the top rope. 9/10. The frog splash was good aswell. It was kinda hard to make out it was a frog splash imo but still smooth and not choppy or stiff. 7.5/10. Overall there animations were my favorite. thats why my vote goes for NGA!
WESton: Wes: It was fairly smooth except the flip. Stiff in the air, but the reaction was good. The changing camera was very weird and it makes it seem that the camera is moving. Good rope bounce. Overall, an average animaton by Wes. 6/10
Blake: The Jump was perfect, but seemed choppy. It was smooth, Helms was stiff when he went to do the frog motion. But overall the best animation of them all. Reaction was also good, The rope bounce was good also. Overall, a very up to standard animation. 8/10
NGA: Mitch: It was slow at the start which I didn't like. It was smooth but the jump was choppy because of how slow it was. The reaction was ok, Not stiff except in the air. Matt was fidgety though which is not good. Overall, A bit better then Wes. 7.5/10
Arrow: Very good animation, But Edge was stiff, and their was no jump, just a fall. Which is pretty realistic actually. Rey's movement was good but to fast. The speed was also to fast. Smooth as well. Table break and reaction were also good. But still to fast. Overall, too fast but if it was slower, it would be the best one. 7.5/10
TheWesstopmotion™: Good animation. It was smooth, but it was a bit slow during the animation. Dolph's arms were stiff during the animation, the camera was not shaky or blurry, and the lighting was good and changed a little during the animation, saw some string, but did not see any shadows or hands in the animation, not fidgety or floaty, Christian needs to be moving more during the flip and stuff, needs more of a squat before going on the top rope, the reaction needs somemore work, and the impact was good though. OVERALL: 6.5/10
TTF4Eva: Good job, it was extremely smooth during the animation, it was not stiff, the camera was not shaky or blurry at all, and the lighting was good and did not change during the animation, saw some string, shadows, or hands in the animation, not fidgety or floaty, Gregory's hip joint could have gone down a little during the squat, also Santino should be moving more during the jump, even though if he did move right before Helms hit him, reaction needs more work, and the impact was great. Average animation from Blake. OVERALL: 8/10
WESton score: 14.5/20
Mitch: It was smooth althrough the animation, it was not too stiff at all, the camera was not shaky or blurry, and the lighting was good and did not change during the animation, saw a tiny bit of string, but did not see any shadows or hands in the animation, Matt was a tiny fidgety on the ground, but not floaty, liked the air that Kurt had on the moonsault, liked the squat before the jumping on the rope, I like how Matt was moving during the backflip, the reaction needs more work and the impact was good. Good job. OVERALL: 7.5/10
Dylanthecat619: Good job, it was smooth, but it was a tiny fast on the frog splash, Edge's arm joints need a bit more of moving, the camera was not shaky or blurry, and the lighting was good and didn't change during the animation, saw no string, shadows, or hands, not fidgety or floaty, I like how Rey was moving during the animation, and Kane also. The squat was good, but you need to bend his hip joint down a bit more for good measures, liked the sound fx, reaction was good, and there was no need for impact. OVERALL: 8/10
NGA Score: 15.5/20
Wrestling Figs Animation Regular Match Record: 2-2-0
Wrestling Figs Animation PPV Match Record: 1-5-0