WF EXTREME RULES: Match 2

[axelwarjp]

"It is now time to deside WF's Animation Begginner's Champion!"

WF Beginner's Title:
Mazin' vs. ~Brett >
Replacement: sabin514
~Create a DDT onto a steel chair

~Brett >:
v5.tinypic.com/player.swf?file=bi13eu&s=5 (click link)

sabin514:

How to vote on matches:
No polls and no suckish replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following:

1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?)

2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended)

If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.

Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.

[jeffhardyfanatic54]

Vote goes to Brett>
His was better and i understood it more,flowed better then sabin's and had a reaction,and sabins looked like it didnt really finish

[Jynxx]

Sabi514-Camera was shakey, it was a little bit choppey, but overall not bad 5/10

Brett-Smooth at the start, but then a bit choppy. camera was really shaley. 3/10

vote:sabin514

[Deleted]

Yikes. This one is tough. Brett's ani was smoother in my eyes. sabin514's was slow. They both weren't as good as I thought they would be.
But my vote goes to: ~Brett>

[bencw]

very close. brett's was confusing, didn't really see impact, but liked the taunt and the reaction. pretty smooth. both were too shaky and stiff. sabins was good but there was no reaction, the animation was too short. very close again, but my vote goes to brett>: 4/10. well done both

[MC2]

Brett:
Not good, The beginning looked good, but the actual DDT was bad, it looked kinda wierd, and it looked like there was an extra frame that shouldt of been there.
Overall: 3.5/10

Sabin514:
Not much better, camera was shaky, but you could actually tell what move he was doing opposed to Brett. You could have had more of a reaction.
Overall: 4/10

Vote: Sabin514

[swantonbombingsd]

They where both ok. Bretts was more realistic than Sabins and just a little bit smoother. They both pretty much get the same rating, but I gotta go with Brett, his was just a little bit better.

BRETT!

["Living Legend" Duttanized]

I'm going with Brett on this one. Both animations were really shakey but Bretts had more impact and was smoother. The background also made it look better.

[wccwmaster]

sabin514 get's my vote in his i could see what was going on and it was tiny bit smooth and not not choppy.

It was sorta bad but better then breet

[Sabin]

I forgot I made that ani lol. This was one of my worst.

[bac5220]

5-3 yay. lol.

Good job sabin.

[P@ul]

Oh god, honestly they are both very bad. Stiff posing in both, shaking camera, bad lighting ... not knowing what the hell is happening. I don't care if it's a beginners title, neither of these two should be getting anything. I would vote for Sabin if I had to.

[bac5220]

Jun 7, 2009 16:18:41 GMT -5 P@ul said:

Oh god, honestly they are both very bad. Stiff posing in both, shaking camera, bad lighting ... not knowing what the hell is happening. I don't care if it's a beginners title, neither of these two should be getting anything. I would vote for Sabin if I had to.

Oh well,


<3 your anis

[wwerulzs24]

They were both ok but choppy

Sabin514
It was good but choppy and the camera was a bit shakey
Overall: 4/10

Brett
It was smooth at first but they it got choppy and the camera was really shakey

Vote: Sabin514


Not moving until orton becomes champion again

[axelwarjp]

~Brett >
I liked the taunt before the move. I saw string. It was really shaky. The reaction was stiff but 'could' be worst.

sabin514
Choppy, camera was shaking. Hardly any reaction really made it worst

Vote: ~Brett >

[TTF4eva]

ooooooooh. uhhhhhhhhh

My vote goes to Brett.
The taunt at the start was great, and the impact of the ddt was great too. Sabins was ok, just it had no reaction, and it didnt really seem like there was no impact on the chair.

[nhwawrestling]

Brett's Was All Pixelated for me and was very shaky while Sabins was Also Shaky slower and Wasnt Pixelated Close but im gonna have to sat Sabin

[michs]

sabin514 - you camra was very shaky, the animation was a bit choppy aswell, very stiff, also no reaction - overall - 4/10

~ brett > - i liked how you had an open chair but the chair could of broken in the reaction, but you had a decent reaction, it was a bit stiff, and bit bit choppy - overall - 5/10

MY VOTE GOES TO ~ BRETT >

[Sabin]

8-6. looks like I lost.

[hjejmnse1]

I wish I entered.