WF Christmas Chaos II : Main Event

[[The Ukrainian One] Dimburuk]

Who will celebrate Christmas as a WF WHC Champion?


WF World Heavyweight Championship
Josh (c) vs Showoff vs KKD
-Stip 1: Corkscrew Shooting Star Press

-Stip 2: Avalanche Sitout Gourdbuster


Stip 1 :


Josh :




Showoff :



Stip 2 :


Josh :




Showoff :



How to vote on matches:

No polls and no suckish replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following:

1) State the username of the person you are voting for.

2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended)

If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.

Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.


VOTING ENDS IN 48 HOURS

[Scotty]

Jush: Wow, really smooth. The bend and jump was great. While on the ground, Cesaro had really realistic movements. Bourne was not stiff at all mid air and wasn't that floaty. Impact and reaction was great. Really great job.
Showshutdown: You didn't use the one I liked better. Punk had alright movements on the ground, his reaction after the move was alright but the fact he didn't try to grab his chest or something after really took away. The move wasn't as smooth as Joshs and seemed a little floaty.
Vote: Jush, Flowed a lot better and smoother

Jush: The liftup was a little stiff and Punks legs were fidgety. Move was smooth but it was really really fast. Punk was stiff in the reaction.
Showoff: Liftup was nice. Rollins was stiff mid air and fidgety in the reaction. Punk wasn't stiff throughout though and had a nice reaction. Pretty slow though.
Vote: Showoff, it was less stiff and had a better reaction.

[wwextreme25]

Good match again guys.

Corkscrew shooting star

Josh:

nice work! Very smooth, i just think maybe too fast? If you maybe delete a few more pics and slow down the speed it would flow better it just looks a little too busy i cant explain it. The impact was great though, liked the reactions too, wouldve been nice to finsih it off with a pin but not a big thing, jut a suggestion. Saw no string, lighting was great. 8/10

Showoff: Really liked this one,especially the attention to detail on the arms of rollins. I loved the movements. Maybe the airtime was a LITTLE slow, unlike josh's which was a little fast so you both needed to find a median speed i guess. Maybe if you sped it up by 0.01 of a second it would've looked a lot nicer airtime, not as floaty, and the impact wouldve been bigger. Still a great animation though, movements were great. I think yours looked a litle more realistic than josh's due to the speed of it, his looked odd to me sorry to be a pain josh, cant explain it. couldve been maybe 8/9 had it had been a litle faster. Saw hardly any faults other than that. Like i said, great movements so yeah, 7.5/10.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Gourdbuster:

Josh: Nice, i liked this one. Airtime was great but the thing that spoiled it all was punks dead impact. He just sat there and did nothing, looked realy unrealistic. Shouldve maybe made him move a little whether its a bump up, or a twist over like showoff did, but thats about the only flaw i saw i think. dolphs reaction was nice also so nice job, very smooth overall, the joint movement was done well and the lighting again was nice. 8/10

Showoff: Really liked this one again man, great movements, great fluidity throughout and unlike josh, you added a nice bounce reactino from punk. The ony flaw here that i didnt like it was punks reaction had 1 frame missing which was only SLIGHTLY noticable and therefore gave a choppy appearence slightly, not following the same flow throughout. Actually, having looked closer rollins' leg movements werent that good as josh's in the air, nonetheless, you having punk have an impact s he hit the mat made all the difference. 9/10

OVERALL:

Josh: 16/20

Showoff: 16.5/20

VOTE: Showoff. Great effort josh, sorry mate. Just thought showoff's realism and joint movements overall tipped te edge for me,

[KKD]

[Colter]

Josh - I really like this animation. Really smooth, and besides Cesaro's reaction (which I considered to be really slow), this is one of my favorite animations.

Showoff - Really nice one here, too. Seemed a little choppy to me, would've been better if sped up. However, I liked the reaction here better than Josh's.

As for Stip 2 - More of the same really. I consider Josh's smoother and while I like the reaction more on Showoff's, I'm gonna have to go with Josh.

VOTE - Josh.

[Deleted]

Stip 1:

Josh: Holy crap, that was possibly the most realistic animation i've ever seen. Finally somebody got the speed of an aerial move right. Normally they look floaty but you nailed it. The joints were perfect, movement, reaction. Everything was just perfect. So proud of you for that, definitely my favourite ani from you

Showoff: The takeoff was odd, seemed like his body moved the opposite way it was supposed to. The spinning looked very odd and unrealistic, was floaty as well. I think you need to make the speed faster as well, as the reaction and impact were good, but they seemed a bit slow. Good animation none-the-less

Stip 2:

Josh: Again, the speed was just perfect. I'm loving it, it's making the moves seem so realistic. I loved the takeoff and the impact/reaction was marvelous, only thing I would of changed is the way Punk kind of just sat there after impact, no real bounce or reaction from Punk. Still one of my favourite animations, i'm loving your recent work

Showoff: I loved the takeoff, made it seem like crap was about to hurt. The impact was good, however the reaction was a bit slow. I did like the reaction though, the way it hurt Punk was a nice touch and I liked Rollins fish effect. Nice joint movement, a really good animation overall.


However i'm going to have to give my vote to Josh, both of his animations seemed flawless. So realistic and his speed really gave it a phenomenal effect. Well done both of you

[ZMW]

Corkscrew shooting star

Josh: Very smooth, just a bit fast. The moving shadows in the background was a bit annoying and really distracted me when watching the animation. The movement in the air was amazing and the rope bounce was great. I loved the movement of the rope when Evan jumped off of it, very realistic! The reaction at the end was slow and stiff, also Cesaro moved slightly forward (Don't know if it was a mistake or part of the reaction) Overall it was a pretty good animation. 9/10

Showoff: Your animation was also very smooth however a bit slow. (Opposite to Josh....Weird...) Anyways, the animation had great movements and it was well edited. Loved how I did not see any shadows nor string which made the animation better. Good rope bounce and I loved the reaction. The pin however looked a bit weird, but oddly realistic. There was a light change near the end which looked a bit weird as well. 8.5/10



Gourdbuster

Josh: The whole animation just looked a bit weird but Ill get back to that. You had the same shadow problem that was in the previous animation which again was a bit annoying, I also saw string in the animation.  The flow of the animation was good but it appeared to switch speed right near the end. The movements were not stiff however a bit choppy. Especially CM Punks arm at the end when it literally snapped backwards. CM Punks head motions near the end made him move slightly and it looked fidgety. Loved the reaction and camera changed. Overall not your best, 6/10

Showoff: The animation was once again slow and I could easily see string in a few frames. The reaction and rope bounce were simply amazing as with the movements however would once again look a lot better if it was sped up. The lift up in the begging looked a tad strange however realistic, (Almost as though he was struggling to lift him). A bit stiff during the move. There was no other disturbances such as shadows and lighting changes in the background. Just like Josh, not your best animation.  7/10

OVERALL:

Josh: 15/20

Showoff: 15.5/20

VOTE: Showoff.

[Deleted]

Josh
Stip 1: Wow. Tbh, this has gotta be one of the smoothest animations you have ever made. I really like this one a lot. The knee bend was nicely done as there was no signs of fidgetyness. The jump into the move was smooth and flowed in the right direction. Now I can't find any flaws on the actual move except it was a tiny bit stiff so try and exaggerate the joints a bit more. The impact was very nice and the reaction was too. Not many flaws with this one. Amazing job overall - 8.5/10
Stip 2: another great one. The whole animation flowed extremely well with no signs of fidgety ness or lack of frames. The pickup was executed well but I would have liked a bit more of a knee bend to show more force being put forth. The move itself flowed well but I felt it was a bit stiff. The impact was great but imo, you could have been a bit more creative with the reaction. Overall, another excellent job. - 8/10

Showoff
Stip 1: I really liked this one. The knee bend was very nice but I wish you put in a little more bend to show the momentum of the move. But I understand it's hard to do that with that figure. The jump was good but I wished you could have had him jump higher instead of just going forward then down. The actual corkscrew thing flowed very well and didn't seem like it lacked any frames. The corkscrew had good joint movement, it was less stiff than josh (lol) and looked very realistic. The impact was good too, overall the move was executed very well. - 8/10
Stip 2: Another smooth ani from you. The knee bend and pickup was nice and wasn't fidgety. The actual move was smooth and flowed very well, the joint movement in it was good (a bit better than Josh's) the impact was really good and I really liked that reaction. Very impact full and creative, Iv'e always liked your reactions. All in all, fantastic job man. - 8.5/10

This was such an extremely close match and a very good one at that. For me it's a tie but I'll try hard to give an actual vote. So, I looked back and I've concluded that this person seemed to put a bit more effort in his animations and as much as I don't like him...

VOTE : Showoff

[Jack]

Sorry in advance that I will have to vote against one of you, but I will try to be as fair and reasonable as possible.

Josh

Stip 1 - I like the knee bend at the start and the thrust of the arms, that was pretty smooth and had a nice flow into the takeoff. I like the speed tbh, if you watch Pac do this move this is the speed he does it has, it is all done pretty quickly so I have no real issue with the speed like others, perhaps it was a small bit too fast, but not as big a deal as some make it out too be. The joint movements were realistic and not over done. Liked how Cesaro caught him into the move and the impact was nice. Only real issue was the Cesaro sit up, just felt a bit too slow for me. Also thought reaction was slightly fidgety but nothing to major. Overall a very nicely done animation.

Stip 2 - I would have preferred their to be a slight knee bend before takeoff just to set up for the momentum of taking off. The whole thing had a really nice flow and was all pretty smooth. Impact was very nice and I liked the reaction by Ziggler, although again part of it just seemed a tad fidgety for me. Zigglers legs were a tad stiff at the start of the mid air but I liked the joint movements before impact. I liked the movements in Punk. 


Showoff

Stip 1 - I liked the knee bend here, and the movements of Rollins hands, they were very nice. The hand movements were very nice here, nice detail also. I did find the shadow a bit annoying and unrealistic for me. I also saw String in your animation and not in Josh's. I just found yours a wee bit floaty tbh, just a tad. Really like the impact, simple but really effective here. Like Josh though part of the reaction did seem a bit fidgety for me. 

Stip 2 - Like Josh I would have preferred a better knee bend to give more momentum in the whole move. I kinda found the part before takeoff a bit fidgety tbh. I liked the flow of the animation as usual and was pretty smooth all the way through. I liked Punks movements in this animation, they were very nice but I felt Rollins was pretty stiff, and the joints weren't moved as well as Josh did in his. I really liked the impact here, and the bounce up was done nicely, although just a tad slow for me. I did find the reactions to be a tad fidgety.

Pretty Close Match, but I will VOTE JOSH just because I felt he had less flaws in his animations in general here throughout. Showoff had quite a few flaws that kinda held his animations back imo. Sorry :3