WF ANIMASSACRE-Match 2

[Andeh]

"Here comes the money..."


Money In The Bank

Andeh Vs. KKD Vs. Fave
-Stip: Shelton Benjamin Ladder Run

Andeh:




KKD:




How to vote on matches

No polls or bad replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following:

1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?)

2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. However you need to compare with the other animations in the match. Put thought into your votes, don't just say who you are voting and leave a sentence, put some effort in.

3) Forum status must be above Jobber

If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.

Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10, but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.

If a title match ends in a draw, the champion retains. (In this case, the title(MITB) would stay vacated and both entrants will get a rematch at a later date)

VOTING ENDS IN 72 HOURS

[wwextreme25]

Wow, what a close match. Not really sure who to vote.

Andeh: Great job here buddy, loved the ladder run - thought it was a little stiff and fidgety in some places but great effort with RA! loved the ladder clothesline tho the fall through mid air was great - again a little stiff - but not too much. Nice impact.

KKD: I thought this was great man! Cesaro's movements were nicely done and the running was amazing. It had a lot better flow compared to andeh's ladder run but i think the clotheslines were tied, both were stiff but had a nice fluid movement.

Vote: KKD. Based on KKD having better running fluidity on the ladder and more realism, i have to give it him, great match

[Jack]

Shame Fave wasn't able to hand in for this.

Andeh - Loved the set up here, looked really good. AJ was a bit fidgety on top of the ladder, but I really love how Benjamin leaned back against the rope before he ran up, nice realism. The running up the ladder was a pretty nice attempt here. It was pretty smooth but it was a bit stiff and slidy for me. The clotheline was really well done, really smooth and had a pretty good flow and impact. Also liked the smoothness of how he left the ring. Well Done. 7.75/10.

KKD - Ok, lighting firstly was not as good as Andeh. Also liked how Rey bounced of the ropes before climbing the ladder. I liked the start of the running of the ladder, nice movements in the knees and the flow was really great. I did feel however that the time he moved over the top of the ladder onto Cesaro it was a bit choppy/lacking some frames. I liked the flow of the fall also, but I have to say, i found Andeh's to be a bit more realistic, in terms off how the impact and reactions were. 7.5/10

Both had their pro's and cons for me which balance up to a similar score. I will however VOTE ANDEH here based on the realism of the animation as well as a better flow of the fall. 

[Scotty]

Andehmania: Was pretty smooth, not that stiff. And the reaction was alright
King Kong Donkey: The running was pretty good, wasn't that stiff and was pretty smooth.
As much as it kills me to do this, gotta go with Kid Kong Donkey, KKD. His was smoother and less stiff.

[el torro]

Andeh: Good job at this, but it wasn't up to par with other animation's you've made. Nice setup, good camera angle, but lighting was a little too dark. The lean on the ropes was a nice touch, and the running itself wasn't great. It looked a little too slow, and seemed rather stiff. The clothesline looked nice, though. Good amount of frames, nice movements on Shelton and the reactions were good too. I liked how Styles fell out of the ring, but the ring moving kind of bugged me.

KKD: Again, not the best I've seen out of you. Lean back was nice, and the running looked better than in Andeh's, but when Rey jumped into the clothesline, it looked like it lacked a good amount of frames, and made it look out of place. The fall also missed a few frames here and there, but the impact was nice. Rope bounce added a nice effect, more-so than Andeh.

I'm going to be completely honest when saying I don't think it's fair if KKD ends up winning the briefcase. He's already in the WHC match next PPV, and say on the slim chance that he does, what happens to the case and then Andeh feels screwed (maybe he won't, who knows). Take that however you like.

VOTE: ANDEH

[Deleted]

KKD-
I really like this ani. the running was very well executed. the clothesline and fall was very smooth and had good joint movement but I felt that the fall was a bit fast imo. the impact and reaction was great. not much else I can say - 7.5/10

Andeh-
another great job from you man. the running up the ladder was good, smooth, but it was stiff and just looked very odd, I don't know what. the clothesline was very good and the fall was also smooth but in my opinion it was stiff and a bit fidgety/fast. the impact and reaction was pretty good but I wasn't a fan of how he fell out of the ring at that speed, a bit fast. but overall, it was very good - 7/10

VOTE: KKD

[Deleted]

Andeh: This had a really nice 2009 feel to it, with the Deluxes, kinda feels like an Angus animation, just like an Angus animation, it was very smooth, had a nice flow but if anything I had to change about that would make it a tiny bit faster in mid-air, joint movement could've been improved, especially AJ's during the build up where it was very un-stable, Shelton could've also used some more arm movement during the running, since they're such big strides he'd be doing more hand movement I'd think, impact was nice but a massive rope bounce would fit in better than a small amount, kinda disappointed you didn't show AJ at the end reacting, would've finished it off nicely.

7.5/10

KKD: Nicely done, animation had a nice flow, but as always, could use some smoothening pics in between, they always seem to be a tad bit choppy, joint movement wasn't great in mid-air, Rey just got into the position with Cesaro and then they just landed down, Cesaro too seemed to land very stiffly with Rey, impact was severely lacking but the reaction was nice, but the kind of trajectory that should be there like with Andeh's was lacking, instead of landing right on the lower back in should've been on his neck, lighting really should be sorted out, besides that it was pretty nice.

5.5/10

Vote: Andeh

[MyyQee™]

Close match..

Andrew: The build up looks fantastic,the running was stiff but wow that impact and that reaction were awesome,like the joint movement on that part of your animation,even though you could moved London,like holding his head or something like that.

KKD:Even you used small ladders you used them very well,your running was great,liked a lot how the rival was just heading up then got hit,did like the impact but reaction was bad in my opinión.

My vote goes to Andrew,the most important part of the animation wich was the impact,the mid air timing and reaction were awesome.

[Jamie]

Great match here!

Andeh: Incredible. The running looked brilliantly done but slightly stiffand joint movement was exceptional. Looked slightly too fast and reaction was pretty good but it would've been interesting to see where the other guy went. Impact was amazing and great build-up. Amazing stuff - 7.5/10

KKD: Amazing. I liked how you added that bounce off of the ropes for build-up - was a little fast though. Lighting could've been better and towards the end it got choppy. Not too choppy but could've used a few extra photos. Reaction was brilliant but the actual connection of the clothesline was very stiff and missed a photo or two. Running looked pretty well done. Great stuff. 6.5/10

VOTE: Andeh

[/X Metal Sorenges x "Mac Oh J~]

My vote goes to KKDarden on this one.

KKDarden: At the beginning I like how you set up the ladder spot with Rey Mysterio bouncing off the ropes, that looked pretty smooth and it helped propel the sequence in motion. The joints were moved very nicely as Rey Mysterio ran up the ladder, I didn't see any stiff in any regard during that portion of the ani but it just seemed a little bit to fast for my preference. I like the reaction Cesero had as Mysterio hit him with the clothesline, it looked pretty prevalent and impactful as well. The spacing in mid air could have been better imo but the impact on the mat was very nicely done along with rope bounce at the end. Nice reaction from both at the end. 9.0/10

Andeh: At the start, I didn't like how Shelton slightly arched his back against the turnbuckle in that fashion, it didn't own any realism imo. The running movements from Shelton wasn't that good, it looked very jumpy and inconsistent with how the arms didn't move very much in essence with the legs and the back but it was still pretty smooth. The clotheline and impact by far was the best aspect of the entire ani, the clothesline itself was absolutely incredible along with impact which caught very single instance of realism I've seen from this move. The slid at the ring looked pretty solid at the end too. 8.8/10