|
Post by Andeh on Nov 18, 2013 10:54:18 GMT -5
"Welcome to WF Animassacre!" *Creepy laugh*
WHC #1 Contenders
*Open Challenge* -Stip: Tiger Driver '98
KKD:
Brandon:
Dustin:
How to vote on matches
No polls or bad replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following:
1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?)
2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. However you need to compare with the other animations in the match. Put thought into your votes, don't just say who you are voting and leave a sentence, put some effort in.
3) Forum status must be above Jobber
If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.
Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10, but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.
VOTING ENDS IN 72 HOURS
|
|
|
Post by Jack on Nov 18, 2013 11:10:20 GMT -5
KKD - Lighting was pretty average tbh even for you, just a bit dark and I felt the camera was a bit too high up. The set up was pretty smooth but I felt Cesaro could have paused before the he lifted him up. The lift up was very smooth and had a nice flow to it. I especially liked the smoothness in the legs and feet of Cesaro, done very well. I did feel Evan was a tad stiff in the air but the impact and reactions of both men were pretty good. 8/10
Brandon - Not your greatest animation here. The lighting was pretty bad, it was also pretty inconsistent which made it worst. I felt the fact you included no build up did make a difference for me here. The whole thing was pretty fidgety as well as pretty floaty in the drop of the move. You could have taken more pictures also in the reaction and impact. 2/10
Dustin - Lighting was the best of the three here. I liked the consistency also in the lighting. Main issue was this didn't really look like the move, it looked like more of a pedigree. You really had to lift up both men in the air to drop him down for the driver. I felt Bryan was fidgety in the small lift up and I felt the impact and reaction were really lacking. The smoothness was pretty good but the flaws and not doing the correct move really, did make a difference. 3/10
Easy win for KKD.
|
|
|
Post by wwextreme25 on Nov 18, 2013 11:14:36 GMT -5
Brandon: Nice effort here buddy. I liked the attempt, flowed quite well but near the end it got a bit choppy/fidgety which ruined the animation a little bit. The lighting started to flicker which became annoying and also the movements were a little off - use a youtube video to help guide you through the movements! Also work on impact as well Dustin. had a bit better flow than brandons however, it all looked too ridged and stiff imo. The guy DB was delivering te move to got no height which ruined impact, and the overall ani itself. Also you wanna try lifting DB off the floor to gain elevation resulting in better impact. KKD: Nice animation. Very smooth as usual and i liked the whole flow. One thing i didnt like was how cesaro floated up in the air. Bend his knees before he jumps to gain elevation but other than that, everything was spot on i think, great job. Vote: KKD for having the most realism and fluidity in his animation.
|
|
|
Post by [The Ukrainian One] Dimburuk on Nov 18, 2013 12:36:33 GMT -5
KKD : Nice job mate. I like the start with Cesaro grabbing Evan's hands, but i feel that he went to pick up Bourne too fast, like without any struggling, that's the only thing that seemed a bit weird to me, but after that i really like the flow, mid-air was pretty good, nice impact, i noticed you tried the rope shake, well it looked cool, but would've been better if all 12 ropes shaked, otherwise reaction was pretty cool and that litle movement from DA Kendrick(London?) is a nice litle touch that i always like Brandon : I guess it's an improvement from previous animations i remember seeing from you. The lighting was cool, but i noticed strings and shadows, so i suggest you kinda try to fix the lighting. I like the pickup but after that it wasn't that good, it was fidgety and choppy, no reaction. I suggest you move the camera a bit more far away from the ring, this angle is too close. Dustin : Pretty simple animation, it was mostly smooth, but there wasn't enough joint movement, and the pickup looked like Bryan just felt and took Rock with him, i suggest you try to move the figures as more as you can so the animation looks more realistic. Vote : KKD, for having the best flow and joint movement.
|
|
|
Post by Scotty on Nov 18, 2013 16:08:49 GMT -5
KikkyDixy: Felt the double underhook into the liftup and piledriver was wayyyy to fast. The move also was choppy midair as Bourne's legs suddenly rotated. The reaction was alright, didn't like the one fans sudden move though. BrandyMan:Didn't like how the double underhook was already applied. The move and lift up were fidgety and went out of focus. The end was fidgety too. Also string was seen. DoneSten: The smoothest of the 3, but pretty much lacked in every other category. Was stiff, had no reaction, etc. Vote goes to KikkyDixy, his had the least amount of flaws.
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: Mar 29, 2024 1:31:56 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Nov 19, 2013 0:41:53 GMT -5
KKD: Nicely done, animation had a good flow, was a tad fast though, it could've used more pics to smoothen it out, Bourne had pretty nice movement but Cesaro could've used some more slight movements during the mid-air part, impact was good but reaction was lacking, should've held his head or something instead of just turning over, lighting was pretty crapty as per usual, you should get that fixed, no string was seen, overall, nicely done. 7/10 Brandon: Not bad, animation's flow was all over the place, the trajectory of the moves and frame rate wasn't good in most places, both Miz and Christian barely moved in mid-air, they were just up and then down, really needed to be pushed up or something like that, just like KKD, impact was there but reaction was lacking, lighting was good for the most part but the out of focus shots annoyed me, saw no string, overall, could use a LOT of work. 2/10 Ganga: Could use a lot of work, animation was smooth and had a pretty nice flow, seemed quite slow though, could've used speeding up, just like Brandon's this one lacked vital movements, but at least you had Bryan move a small bit instead of not at all, there was no impact or reaction, Rock just landed and didn't move afterwards, really could've done more, lighting was pretty good but I saw some bits of string, just like Brandon's, a lot more work is needed. 2.5/10 Vote: KKD
|
|
MyyQee™
Main Eventer
Un hobbie jamás se deja..
Joined on: Jan 2, 2010 1:06:52 GMT -5
Posts: 1,246
|
Post by MyyQee™ on Nov 19, 2013 10:52:16 GMT -5
Good match to start the PPV!
KKD:Your animation flows very well but I can see some flaws in it,you could bend the knees of both figures before the lift,so it wouldn´t see like a bit floaty because Cesaro just jumped from no impulse,the light is way too dark and even the rope bounce is a nice addition I just see the front ropes moving,you had the most fluid animation,I like the impact and had a decent reaction,even you didn´t bend the knees,it´s the best from the three.
Brandon:Alright,compare to the first animation the lighting was great,camera angle didn´t help too much,was blurry and pretty fidgety,didn´t moved the joints well and I see lot of string troughout the animation,didn´t like the reaction.
Dustin:Was smooth but the main problema with this was the lift,didn´t seem the stip,had a good flow,I don´t agree with build ups because the main thing is the move itself so I don´t complain about that,string was seen and dead reaction didn´t help.
My vote goes to KKD,had the best flow and to be honest the difference between this animations was remarkable,good luck buddy.
|
|
Jamie
Main Eventer
Joined on: Sept 14, 2013 15:54:23 GMT -5
Posts: 3,380
|
Post by Jamie on Nov 19, 2013 15:29:55 GMT -5
KKD: Wow, amazing stuff! Looked pretty smooth and the joint movement was strong. The fact that you moved Kendrick in the crowd who was barely seen was a nice touch. Reaction was good but could've been better. Great stuff though! 8/10
Brandon: Nice effort. String was noticeable and camera was shaky. Figures were very fidgety but the joint movement was okay throughout. More pictures needed to be taken and reaction was very fidgety. Nice job. 2.5/10
Dustin: Nice stuff! String was noticeable in the beginning but wasn't a setback. I felt that the lighting could've been better but it was fine. Joint movement was alright but needed some work. Looked good smoothness wise but reaction needed some more effort. Nice job here. 4.5/10
VOTE: KKD
|
|
|
Post by /X Metal Sorenges x "Mac Oh J~ on Nov 19, 2013 18:28:04 GMT -5
My vote goes to KKDarden.
Brandon: Good effort you have here Brandon. At the beginning I like the flow in the lift up but both Miz and Christian were a little bit stiff in their knees during the transition overall. The double underhook was somewhat smooth throughout but the lighting had a very uneasy disposition within the last couple of frames of the animation, the movements from both Christian and Miz were pretty fidgety as well. The Miz was a little stiff in his back going towards impact, during the initial impact, there could have been a few more pictures and the consistent commensurate rate of fidget made the ani's fluency very counteractive imo. The impact at the end could have been better. 5.0/10
Dustin: At the beginning I like how you had Daniel Bryan reach for the Rock to set up the move rather then have a pre-positioned stance. The animation itself wasn't bad at all, although their was some string visible it flowed very well, it was smooth and had pretty decent fluency imo. The speed suited well for this particular move it seems so good job there. The move itself however could have used alot more height in regards to having the Rock in the air more vertically though. The Rock and Daniel didn't seem stiff throughout and I really like the impact at the end but the Rock could have had more of a reaction at the end. 7.0/10
KKDarden: At the beginning I really like how you had Cesero lift Bourne's arms when setting up for the move itself, that looked very smooth all in itself. Before the initial lift-up, there should have been a squat at the end to show Cesero gaining momentum within the lift and concentrate on the driving power within. Regardless without the mid-section the ani turned out very well, either Cesero or Bourne looked stiff at all. The jump from Cesero in mid air had great air time although it did look a little floaty in mid air. The impact was good but Bourne could have used a few more frames going down towards the canvas as it looked a tad choppy. 8.5/10
|
|