SUMMER CATASTROPHE III: MAIN EVENT (Part 2/3)

[Deleted]

World Heavyweight Championship Retirement match

Angus(c) vs Arrow
Stip: 3 Stages of Hell match
First fall: Freestyle with no weapons
Second fall: Falls count anywhere Freestyle
Third fall: Ladder match Freestyle



Angus:


Arrow:




How to vote on matches:

1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?)

2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended)

If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.

Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.


VOTING FOR SECOND FALL ENDS IN 24 HOURS

[Deleted]

Angus - Great work! The movements were nice and so was the creativity. The taunt before the move was a nice touch and was pretty smooth. The twists were very well executed and so was the move. I saw a bit of string, but was very fluid. The camera pan was nice and smooth, not choppy nor awkward, and the reaction was decent but I think Michaels should've done more than kicked his legs up a bit.

Arrow - Great work also! The springboard was nice but a bit stiff when he was about to land on the rope; Rey was completely straight which was weird. Some string was noticeable but it was very smooth although somewhat slow. The hurricanrana was very nicely animated and the reaction was good. The extra crowd movements were very affective.

Vote - Arrow

[el torro]

Angus: Nice job on this, man. Overall it was pretty smooth and had a good flow, however, there are a handful of things that bugged me. First off, I like Shawn's taunt in the beginning, and how you were moving Punk, but after a while, it's almost like you forgot to move him. He moved, stopped for a brief time, and then moved again. To me, it just seemed off, and I did not like the frequent camera moving. The cartwheel was really well done and the transition to the Canadian Destroyer was excellent. Punk, I felt, was a bit stiff during the move and Shawn's reaction was really late. I did see some string throughout, so that was a bit annoying.

Cam: Superb job on this. All the little details made this a great ani. The knee bend from Rey was well done, though could've used an extra frame or two. I really liked how you moved the fan's heads throughout, that was a real nice touch. Rey's springboard was nice, but I noticed some blurry pictures and string, and his arms were pretty stiff. Yoshi's movements preparing for the move were nice as well, and the 'rana was excellent. Real good joint movements from both figures, though I think Rey should've reacted more from the landing, maybe play it off as if he hurt his ankle or something, and Yoshi's impact towards the move wasn't that great. Again, good addition moving the fans.

VOTE: Cam
Better flow, looked smoother, and overall I think better animated

[JDP]

Angus: Awesome ani, the setup was really cool for starters. The cartwheel was fantastic and flowed very nicely, the landing of the cartwheel and the twist into the 180 senton had a good frame rate, nice speed, and good joint movement. The canadian destroyer itself was great and the camera angle change was nicely done, the canadian destroyer flowed well also. The reaction was good and it was animated greatly. Well done.

Arrow: Also a great animation, the springboard was nice and smooth as always and the joint movement and frame rate flowed together well. The hurricane rana had good joint movement and in your animations as always it had a great flow. The reaction was good and I liked how Yoshi grabbed his neck and moved his back up because it made it seem more effective and realistic, also cool how you had the crowd react.


Vote: All three stips are freestyle, and so far both of you have made to very good overall animations, and you have used your creativity, but imo I liked Angus's ani more than Arrows this round.


Awesome match so far.

[wwextreme25]

Both anis were great.

Arrow: nice ani from you not much i could see wrong with it other than i dont like reys movements in the springboard. Although you moved the joints, the way rey moved still seemed kinda stiff such as mid air just before he hit the ropes. I didnt like reys knee position coming into the rana setup. Again the legs were stiff and they shouldve had at least a SLIGHT bend in them. Finally the speed of the ani annoyed me. Shouldve all been sped up by 0.01 and it wouldve looked a lot better imo. and yes, that extra 0.01 DOES make a difference. Great crowd movements though very realistic i dunno how you do them so well.

Angus: Loved the creativity in this. It was done really well and i dont know where you get the ideas from! The cartwheel was nice but i saw a little bit of string. Not a big problem though as it wasnt really that noticeable. The cartwheel was animated well but i loved the canadian destroyer. Was done so well. The transition from the cartwheel into the canadian destroyer was incredible and the destroyer itself was very smooth and animated well. Nice impact but i felt shawns couldve had a little better one.

Vote: Angus because i preferred his creativity and i thought it flowed better in regards to speed and fluidity. Cams seemed a little too slow and wasnt as creative as angus'. Great effort though cam!

[Deleted]

Angus: I really liked this one Angus, had a great flow through-out with a perfect amount of frames through-out, the joint movement was good but I felt that Punk's movements in preparation were too sporadic and too jumpy, the mid air part was good movement wise to the actual move but I would've liked more movement from HBK after the move, onto the reaction, I liked it but I really didn't like the random stalling during it, although not an issue wiin the animating it really shouldn't have been included, (not gonna take off points for it), the lighting was good through-out but the camera was a bit shaky at the start, I also saw a few strings but nothing bad, really nice to see you go out with a bang Angus.

9.5/10

Arrow Wilson: Another really nicely done move here Mr. Wilson, had a great amount of frames through-out but the speed/flow wasn't great and seemed quite slow, the joint movement again was good, but as a whole I didn't like it as much as Angus', the movements should've been a bit more exaggerated than Angus' but it was even less and was very simple, the reaction was good too but I would've liked it to be a little more exaggerated one, the lighting was great and I saw a few bits of string, really nice job here Cam, I just have to vote for Angus because of the more accurate movement, I do think think that regardless of my vote, this will be your time.

9/10

Vote: Angus

[jwsowner]

Angus: Very nice! I love the move! High Points: The cartwheel was excellent. The flow of the transition into the C.D. was great. Nice impact from Punk. Low Points: Punk was not moving much when HBK cartwheeled, but when he did, it was only for a frame or two. Camera moved quite a bit, HBK's reaction was delayed. A bit choppy from Punk at the end.

Arrow: Creative rana, you got here. High Points: Perfectly animated. Very smooth. Great crowd reaction and reaction/impact. Low Points: A little too slow on the reaction.

Vote: Arrow, it flowed better overall.

[/X Metal Sorenges x "Mac Oh J~]

My vote goes to Angus.

Angus: I absolutely love this animation here Angus, this was very nicely done and the amount of smoothest you're able to maintain with just RA's is just astounding to me quite frankly. I like the taunt at the beginning by HBK, the cartwheel from HBK was very smooth, it flowed very well and it had it probably fluent motions possible for a cartwheel imo. The jump spinning was pretty smooth, the air time was perfect and the spacing was also excellent. I noticed that CM Punk movements looked a little choppy and the camera angle change somewhat distracted from the quality of the ani a bit but nothing detrimental of course. The Canadian Destroyer was a little slow in mid air but it was smooth and the flow was out of this world though. The impact was good and I like the reaction at the end. 9.8/10

Arrow: At the beginning I like the squat from Rey Mysterio, it was quite smooth. I really don't like the jump in this animation, it had a few blurry pictures in mid air and although this may be a personal preference, I feel like you should over exaggerate the joint movement in your jumps a bit more and Rey Mysterio was a little stiff in his arms as well. The transfer over into the hurricanarana was smooth but I felt like you should have been Mysterio's knees a little bit but I really like how Yoshi Tatsu was aware of how was throughout, that was very nicely done. The impact was good but I didn't like the reaction very much from Yoshi. 9.0/10

[Deleted]

Angus: Very nice job, but the whole thing just seems, off for me. The move set seems unrealistic to perform in real life, but not in the animation world, it was done well but personally I think it would have looked better if the fig was running instead of doing flips and cartwheels, also in the beginning the string is very noticeable and that bugs me a lot, but as far as the rest of the video goes, once more perfect, that destroyer was awesome, but the video seems to fast for my liking, but still, nice job.
8.6/10

Arrow: Good job, but the whole animation just seems stiff and slow. When Rey jumps up onto the third rope there is some string showing, but other than being slow and stiff, it was an awesome job, very realistic, great reaction from Tatsu, very good animation.
8.5/10

These are way to hard to judge, I mean both of you did a outstanding job, both showed some string, and both were either a little fast or a little slow for my liking, but Angus gets the win for me becuase of the wave at the beginning, thought it was a nice touch.

WINNER: ANGUS

[Andeh]

Woooooow

Angus: Insane. Such a cool animation, the taunt at the beginning set the animation up nicely. Joint movements where great throughout the cartwheel and into the backflip. Extremely smooth and the camera angle change was nice. The lift off from Punk was good however I thought you should have moved his ankle joints as he is flat footed throughout the flip. The impact was awesome, Punk bouncing off the ground and flying into the wall was sweet. I saw string throughout :/
However the creativity and sheer wow factor is what separates the WHC from the other titles on this board. Incredible animation.

8.5/10

Arrow: Its a real clean animation and its great but it lacks the wow factor. The joint movements where great throughout and extremely smooth. The impact was decent and the reaction was simple. There are alot of blurry pics during the Rana aswell. Overall I think it lacks big time. I'm not saying you need to do a sasuke special into a canadian destroyer to win, but if you are going to make a Rana atleast make it look awesome. Its just a standard Rana. Not WHC Material IMO.

7/10

My vote goes to Angus on this fall.