Ross
Main Eventer
Joined on: Nov 21, 2008 9:43:29 GMT -5
Posts: 3,154
|
Post by Ross on May 31, 2013 12:04:47 GMT -5
"Welcome to the No Strings Attached II Dark show!"
High Flyers #1 Contenders.
SuperBradOPig Vs. TheViper9o21o Vs. Josh Vs. emwjoey Vs. Dimburuk Vs. BFG -Stip: Lionsault
SuperBradOPig:
TheViper9o21o:
Josh:
emwjoey:
Dimburuk:
BFG:
How to vote on matches:
No polls and no suckish replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following:
1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?)
2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended)
If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.
Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.
VOTING ENDS IN 48 HOURS
|
|
SuperBradOPig
Main Eventer
Hello there.
Joined on: Nov 23, 2012 18:12:22 GMT -5
Posts: 1,102
|
Post by SuperBradOPig on May 31, 2013 12:34:15 GMT -5
God Damn it Josh and Dimburuk
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: Apr 19, 2024 22:32:46 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 31, 2013 12:40:35 GMT -5
Came down to Josh and Dima.
Josh - The running needed work. I think if you lifted him up more then it would've been great. The jump was nice and smooth and the Moonsault was nice. The reaction was really nice and I liked how punk was moving throughout the animation.
Dima - The running was nice and I liked it better than Josh's. The jump onto the rope was nice as well and the Moonsault was nice also. I liked the reaction from both but Cara seemed fidgety when putting his arm on Orton.
Nice match here, but my vote goes to Josh.
|
|
Leones
Mid-Carder
Nobody can touch me.
Joined on: May 27, 2012 15:44:06 GMT -5
Posts: 332
|
Post by Leones on May 31, 2013 12:50:35 GMT -5
It came down to Josh and Dima.
Josh: Very smooth, awesome camera quality which makes it look better, perfect flow, just the only thing that let you down was the running, kind of weird, need some work, because it looks like a fast walk instead of a running. Well done on mid air, nice impact and reactions!
Dima: Not so smooth as Josh, lacked some pictures, the running was kinda fast and cartoonish (I hope you know what I mean), a bit floaty on mid air, good reaction and impact!
WINNER: Josh
|
|
|
|
Post by el torro on May 31, 2013 13:43:02 GMT -5
Came down to Josh and Dimburuk.
Josh: Great animation here, man. The taunt in the beginning was nice and I liked how you made Punk move throughout Jericho's taunt. The running however, though it did have nice leg joint movement, it didn't really look as if Jericho moved his arms at all so that kinda bugged me. Now the jump and springboard looked really nice and smooth and the impact looked really nice. Both reactions were well done and smooth as well.
Dimburuk: Solid ani from you, Dim. Same as Josh, again, I like the taunt you added in the beginning and how you made Randy move a bit throughout. The running although looked like there was only one step looked a bit better than Josh's since you moved Cara's arms. Nice jump and springboard, but the air time looked fidgety and floaty. I think Orton moved his arm's too early as well and the reaction from both men could've been better.
VOTE: JOSH
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: Apr 19, 2024 22:32:46 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 31, 2013 14:25:44 GMT -5
Dammit Josh and Dimburuk... why do you guys have to be so good?!?!?!?!?!
|
|
|
|
Post by Scotty on May 31, 2013 15:05:29 GMT -5
I understand I've done it before, but its really unfair to the rest of the guys in the match by just saying "it came down to" ...
SuperBradPig: Really slow. The ring was really fidgety and the camera moved a lot. Slater? had movements that were way to fast and more pics were either needed or less movement was to make it better. Cara was fidgety and stiff mid air. He was also pretty floaty mid air. Didn't like the blue tack on the ropes either, and the editing could have been better.
Viper: A lot smoother than brads. Still had a couple of fidgety spots too, such as the look down. Punks movements were unrealistic and very fidgety. He moved an arm up then did some crunches. Then he no sold and rolled over. You should have had him react to the move and sell it more. Gabriels movements were pretty good and not that stiff. He had a decent reaction.
Josh: The best so far, incredibly smooth. I like the taunt in the beginning and PUnks movements were great and realistic. The running was nice as was the lionsault, great job. Only flaw is really y2j twisting sideways after landing down. Continue to prove me wrong.
Joey: Very fidgety. Zeke moved a lot and both him and Jomo needed their joints moved more.
Dinkleburg: Orton had nice movements, although his arms raised too early and didn't come down quick enough. His legs should have moved too. Cara's running was nice and the lionsault was smooth. Was a little stiff mid air though. The reaction was fidgety too.
BFG: Very fidgety and slow. Move the joints more, take more pictures.
Winner is Joshua because his had the least amount of flaws.
|
|
JDP
Main Eventer
WFigs biggest Justin Gabriel fan.
Joined on: Aug 22, 2012 2:09:11 GMT -5
Posts: 3,561
|
Post by JDP on May 31, 2013 21:24:57 GMT -5
Pretty close match, it narrows down to Josh and Dima, and I have to go with Josh.
Josh: I liked this animation, the taunt you had at the beginning was effective and made it have a more realistic feel. I liked how you moved the joints in the running but I personally liked Dima's running just a bit more. The move it's self was very nice and wasn't fidgety at all. I liked the impact but it seemed weird how it just ended with Jericho laying on Punk's legs.
Dima: I thought yours had a good flow, seemed a little bit choppy in comparision to Josh's but still a great animation. I prefer your running over Josh's because it seemed less fidgety and the legs weren't bent down too much. I liked the lionsault, it was smooth and I liked how you bent Cara's knees but when you brought Cara down to Orton for the move to be completed it seemed like you didn't move the joints as much as you did previously. The taunt and reaction at the end was nice and wasn't fidgety.
Good showing by everyone.
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: Apr 19, 2024 22:32:46 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on May 31, 2013 21:58:12 GMT -5
Brad: Really slow, the string editing wasn't that great and it is kind of distracting. The moonsault needs more work and the reaction can be improve. Keep workin.
Viper: Running was pretty choppy, moonsault was a little slow and stiff. Otherwise, good job.
Josh: I like how you made Punk move his arms while Jericho was running. The running was great,however, it would've looked better if Jericho lifted his legs up more. The moonsault was smooth but I felt like you could've moved the joints more to make it look not stiff. Well other than that, this was a great animation from you, good job.
emwjoey: Seemed like he was walking instead of running. The moonsault seemed pretty choppy too, impact needs some work.
dim: i liked the taunt at the begininng, the running was good but I thought the moonsault was unrealistic and a bit stiff. The reaction was pretty good.
bfg: it looked choppy, i didn't like how the camera changed angle during the jump. You should've added more reaction and maybe get all the figures in one frame. Not half of their body.
Vote: Josh
|
|
Fave
Main Eventer
Who survived and what was left of them?
Joined on: Jul 20, 2010 20:06:52 GMT -5
Posts: 3,607
|
Post by Fave on Jun 1, 2013 13:13:19 GMT -5
TheViper9o21o: Pretty decent animation you got here. I think the running had very few frames which made it look almost non existant so next time i would suggest having the attacker start off farther back. The moonsault itself was smooth and it had nice joint movement but i didnt like how he just came off the ropes and flipped in the same location; looked really unrealistic but understandable due to amount of the space you have to work with. Impact was good but lack of rope bounce and reaction made it seem not as powerful. 6.5/10
Josh: Very cool taunt at the start, i liked the speed and fluidity of it. The running had one too many steps i felt and just lengthening the strides of one step can help tremendously. I like how you moved Punk the entire time very subdetly as to not make it so obvious but evident at the same time which helped with realism. The jump and flip were amazingly smooth and the speed was right on. Nice impact and reaction too. 9/10
emwjoey:: I'm not familiar with you as i don't believe i've seen your animations before but assuming you're a beginner i'd say you're not bad. The animation itself was okay. A few flaws i'd like to point out are Zekes movements during the entire animation. I don't believe they were needed and the lionsault lacked pictures. Try moving the joints more and taking more pictures. 5/10
Dimburuk: I liked the taunt at the start and you had the best running out of everyone. The jump and moonsault were smooth but i didn't like the position of Cara's feet. I think the impact and reaction are what let it down though. They weren't nearly as good as the rest of the animation. 8.5/10
BFG: Not really a fan of this animation. Seemed like ADR didn't even touch the ropes at all the entire time and just floated upwards then back. There was many blurry pictures and the camera angle is a bit too close. It had a flow going to it though so ill give you that. 4/10
Vote: Josh
|
|
SuperBradOPig
Main Eventer
Hello there.
Joined on: Nov 23, 2012 18:12:22 GMT -5
Posts: 1,102
|
Post by SuperBradOPig on Jun 1, 2013 13:40:43 GMT -5
TheViper9o21o: Pretty decent animation you got here. I think the running had very few frames which made it look almost non existant so next time i would suggest having the attacker start off farther back. The moonsault itself was smooth and it had nice joint movement but i didnt like how he just came off the ropes and flipped in the same location; looked really unrealistic but understandable due to amount of the space you have to work with. Impact was good but lack of rope bounce and reaction made it seem not as powerful. 6.5/10 Josh: Very cool taunt at the start, i liked the speed and fluidity of it. The running had one too many steps i felt and just lengthening the strides of one step can help tremendously. I like how you moved Punk the entire time very subdetly as to not make it so obvious but evident at the same time which helped with realism. The jump and flip were amazingly smooth and the speed was right on. Nice impact and reaction too. 9/10 emwjoey:: I'm not familiar with you as i don't believe i've seen your animations before but assuming you're a beginner i'd say you're not bad. The animation itself was okay. A few flaws i'd like to point out are Zekes movements during the entire animation. I don't believe they were needed and the lionsault lacked pictures. Try moving the joints more and taking more pictures. 5/10 Dimburuk: I liked the taunt at the start and you had the best running out of everyone. The jump and moonsault were smooth but i didn't like the position of Cara's feet. I think the impact and reaction are what let it down though. They weren't nearly as good as the rest of the animation. 8.5/10 BFG: Not really a fan of this animation. Seemed like ADR didn't even touch the ropes at all the entire time and just floated upwards then back. There was many blurry pictures and the camera angle is a bit too close. It had a flow going to it though so ill give you that. 4/10 Vote: Josh *Cough Cough* |
|
|
|
Post by /X Metal Sorenges x "Mac Oh J~ on Jun 1, 2013 19:52:47 GMT -5
My vote goes to Josh.
SuperBradOPig: Nice attempt at the Lionsault here Brad. At the beginning it would have been nice to see running going towards the ropes as the movements were very slow and didn't really flow well. The transition into the jump onto the top rope was a little bit choppy and floaty. The Lionsault itself was a little bit choppy and the slow. The impact wasn't half bad but Christian looked a bit fidgety afterwards and the reaction from both Sin Cara and Christian could have been better.
TheViper9o21o: At the beginning I really didn't like how you had to many pictures of Gabriel looking down at CM Punk. It just didn't give the animation a good flow and it doesn't seem very realistic with the length you had it playing out. It would have been better you just did two frames of each leg going forward a little bit like slid walking rather then attempting running while in such a close quarters space, it made it look very awkward and choppy. The jump onto the middle rope for the Lionsault was very nicely done, but the Lionsault itself could have used better spacing and Gabriel seemed a stiff in his torso/legs. It seemed pretty impactless after the Lionsault but there really wasn't much you could do so that's understandable. Nice ani.
Emwjoey: At the start, I thought the walking towards the middle rope could have been better as the movements were very small and could have been utilized better. Ezechiel Jackson was very fidgety on the mat and it didn't look very good at all. The jump onto the middle rope from John Morrison was very choppy and Morrion seemed rather stiff in his arms, legs and torso as well. The impact was ok but that was a tad choppy and the reaction needed more work.
Dimburuk: Nice animation you have here Dimburuk. At the beginning I like the taunt from Sin Cara, the running was alright but I felt that if you bent Sin Cara's knees a little bit more it would have flowed much better then it initially did. The jump onto the middle rope looked smooth but it looked very stiff, Sin Cara didn't bend his knees or more his arms going into it which takes away from the animation a bit. The Lionsault was pretty good, but it was a little slow and choppy about mid way through in mid air. There could have been more impact and same can be said about the reaction.
BFG: This could use alot of work BFG, I didn't like how at the beginning you instantly changed the camera upon setting up for the Lionsault. There wasn't any type of jump and it was very choppy and fidgety overall. The lionsault need alot of pictures in mid air and Del Rio was very stiff as well. I really like the impact and reaction through. Keep at it BFG.
Josh: Really nice animation you have here Josh. At the beginning I like the taunt but the attempt at running towards the ropes I just feel like the spacing for the movements were just a tad off or something along those lines. I really like how you had Chris Jericho lead his feet slowly on the ropes, it was a very effective touch rather then a jumping motion and it was very smooth overall. The Lionsault was very smooth, I honestly didn't see any flaws during that portion of the animation. The impact was good and nice reaction at the end.
|
|
