WF Animania XI - Match 6

["Living Legend" Duttanized]

"In your world, I'm godddd!"



Grudge Match:
Arrow Vs wwestevo07
-Stip: Any move involving exploding barbed wire.



Arrow:





wwestevo07:





How to vote on matches:

No polls and no suckish replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following:

1) State the username of the person you are voting for. (should I even have to say this?)

2) You must give reason on why you have voted this person as the winner. (Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended)

If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions.

Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.




VOTING ENDS IN 48 HOURS

[Deleted]

ARROW: Great animation here Can, it was incredibly smooth through-out, one of your top features is how good a flow they have, Cena could've used more movement for the first half of the animation where Punk picked him up and taunted, although the running was a bit stiff, I liked how Cena moved up a bit just before the jump, but the overall stiffness needed work, Cena could've used a much bigger reaction, he just moved his arms up a little... ::yawn:: The lighting was good as always and I saw a few pieces of string, not bad Cam, but with a few little improvements, it would've been much better.

7.5/10

WWESTEVO07: Great animation as always Stevo, incredibly smooth through-out, like usual, Dolph and Punk had perfect movement through-out the move, but after it was done Punk was stiff and could've moved a lot more, still good movement though, Dolph's reaction was great, perfect over the top one for the move, the lighting was good as always and I didn't see any string, great stuff Stevo, nothing else to say about it now though.

9.5/10

Vote: WWESTEVO07

[wwextreme25]

Arrow: Really liked the animation here. The first flaw i see is punk just picked up cena without cena having any movement. For it to look more realistic you wanna have cena bend his knees or something, kinda similar to what stevo did with the tiny hop before lift up but add a bend. Cenas little leg twitch whilst punk had him up was realistic and unlike josh, i dont think you needed anything more there otherwise it wouldve look overdone. Kudos for animating running as well as you did with two figures - the speed was well created i just though cena shouldve overselled his reaction instead of punk as punk seemed to have a worse off reaction than cena and he only gave the move. Finally, the string, obviously, is the final factor that ruined the ani but it wasnt a major flaw, just something to pick up on. Overall a nice ani. 8/10

Stevo: Really liked it here. YOu did add the little hop im talking about before the lift up but i stil dont think you execute it right. You should have the victim bend his knees, lift up in the "hop" and then go back down bending his knees for lift up. You just had dolphs legs stay stiff. However, i know the joints wont allow it but maybe move the figure back a few steps so they bend (i know this from my orange crush bomb stip we did in our match). anyway, its not a major flaw, just a very minor detailed one. The movements in the lift up were incredible and i didnt see any string nor did i see any glimpses of fidgetyness/stiffness so great job. The throw from punk was really really nice and i loved how you had zigger oversell in a way only zigger knows how great idea having the table fall down with dolph aswell, LOVED that attention to detail. Finally, a slight nit pick is that i didnt like how i could see sparks all around the screen when they shouldve only been around the table area imo. Overall a great ani. 8.5/10

Vote: Stevo.

Reason: I think his had fewer flaws than cam, and flowed better. He added more attention to the smaller detailed parts of the ani that cam missed, which made for a more realistic animation (besides the sparks which is a minor issue as its fx, not animation). Great match though.

[Deleted]

Great match.

Arrow: A good animation from you, the lift was pretty good. Cena could've moved his arm more while being on the piledriver position. The running was very nice, and the jump before the landing added some nice taste to the animation. The impact was very well done, but cena could've reacted more, done and the effects were quite good. 8.5/10

Stevo: A good animation from you, i really like the set up. The jump before the powerbomb made it all realistic. The pickup was nice and the speed was quite perfect. I just thought the only flaw here was Punk's fall after the powerbomb, other than that... The reactions were incredible and the effects were priceless, awesome job stevo. 9/10

Vote: Stevo

[GAm3r357]

Arrow: Nice job here man. The lift up was nice and smooth, but the string was distracting. I loved the running in the animation as it was realistic and had a good speed but cena seemed stiff. During the second part of the fall, cena was noticably starting to move making it not as stiff anymore but i thought cenas reaction was lame as he didnt move much after being hit with an explosion. Then again, i suppose thats realistic as, it is cena and he doesnt sell nice job overal though 8/10

Stevo: Really liked this. The realism you put in was really nice! Love the little jump you had before the main lift up - really realistic. The way you had punk Throw ziggler then jump out of the way was an awesome addition to the animation but its a table, and i though ziggler shouldve gone through it not bounce off it. Nonetheless great work with the oversell and the whole thing was smooth as hell. Nice job. 8.5/10

Vote: stevo

[Cooperman]

Arrow : Really nice ani dude, has to be one of my favs from you. It was really smooth trough-out. It wasn't fidgety and I didn't notice shadows. The running looked really good and I can imagine the troubles you had to do it with the victim lifted. The jump made the Powerbomb. The reaction looked fine too. I noticed a bit of stiffness before the powerbomb but I can't bitch about it knowing the move itself is stiff. Could have made Cena struggle a bit before the impact tho.

Stevo : The first lift was awesome. It made the ani look really realistic. The whole thing was so smooth and the joints movements were amazing. The lift was really well done, and so was the throw. The reaction was really nice and the oversell just made it better. I can't see anything to be picky about besides Punk after the move. Didn't like how he just 'sat' there. A taunt or something would've made it better. It still didn't affect the ani that much.

Arrow did an awesome job, but Stevo had a more realistic ani & his' was less stiff than Arrow's. I vote for Stevo.

[Deleted]

Vote WWESTEVO
They both flowed well and were good animations. Stevos seemed to be a bit more realistic tho. I did not like seeing Arrows string and Stevos explosion seemed to be a bit more realistic.

[Deleted]

Arrow really great ani from you the pick up was nice and the running was great along with the Impact but overall the whole ani seemed robotic it didn't have the realism factor that Stevos had and I also saw a few wires overall 9 out of 10

Stevo this is one of your best anis ever the pick up was perfect and the barbed wire board you made looked awesome the pick up was good and the throw was awesome the explosion I felt looked just as good as arrows and the impact dolph had you could really feel unlike arrow you gave it more realism which is why I'm giving you a 10 out of 19

Vote Stevo

[Deleted]

Wwe Steven as he follows the stipulation the other competitor has an explosion but its not exploding barbed wire like the stop reads. There is an unrealistic explosion when cents head hits but there was no reaction I cenas head hitting it or smoke to make it look like something went off.

Steven 9.5 flowed like a river, pyro looked reall well it sen Ziggler out thought he was coming out the screen!!

Archer 6.5 I thought the animation was solid but the explosion was weak it is a cool. Effect but it doesn't look realistic I suggest watching some fmw videos from Japan.

[Deleted]

Apr 21, 2013 18:20:32 GMT -5 @cloudwalker said:

Wwe Steven as he follows the stipulation the other competitor has an explosion but its not exploding barbed wire like the stop reads. There is an unrealistic explosion when cents head hits but there was no reaction I cenas head hitting it or smoke to make it look like something went off.

Steven 9.5 flowed like a river, pyro looked reall well it sen Ziggler out thought he was coming out the screen!!

Archer 6.5 I thought the animation was solid but the explosion was weak it is a cool. Effect but it doesn't look realistic I suggest watching some fmw videos from Japan.

Ummm, I did follow the stip. Also I have no idea what you said aside from the first sentence. ._.