|
Post by "Living Legend" Duttanized on Mar 2, 2012 1:58:07 GMT -5
"Finally this match is up! Which 2 are going to AniMania?"Survival of the Fittest LKS vs Wes vs buzzer vs Fave vs Myyqee vs Scott vs Josh vs M vs TurrahStips(oKANEo) s129.photobucket.com/albums/p232/bik100/?action=view¤t=muscle_buster.gifLKS:Wes:buzzer:No Turn-in. Fave:Myyqee:Scott:Josh:No Turn-in. M:No Turn-in. Turrah:No Turn-in. How to vote on THIS MATCH: No polls and no suckish replies. Your vote will only and only count if you do the following: 1) State the usernames of the people that you are ranking, as there are only 5 people who handed in, rank them from 1st to fifth. I will figure out the point tabulation by myself. 2) You must give reason on why you have voted this people into their ranking positions.(Could be anything from smoother animation, to most creative. Compare other's animation is recommended) If you cannot complete these simple rules, then your vote won't count and will be deleted on the spot, no exceptions. Note: Alot of users like to get a mark out of 10 (or 5 if you must), but I can't force you to give a mark. Just take it to consideration when voting to make a mark to compare each animation in the match.
|
|
|
Post by jake4698 on Mar 2, 2012 4:50:33 GMT -5
I vote for LKS to be N.1. His animation seemed the most realistic to me and more like a Muscle Buster than others'. Also, his' was probably the smoothest. I also liked how Punk turned/flip and it had a really nice ammount of light. I didn't see shadows or strings and the camera wasn't shaking. I also think that he had the best angle of pictures. In the other hand, his animation wasn't stiff (at all ?) and it had a really nice reaction. I vote for Myyqee to be N.2. Myyqee gets the second place because I beleive, he had the second best animation out of all of these. He had a really great lighting, we couldn't notice shadows or strings, and his camera wasn't shaking. His move seemed like a Muscle Buster and his figures weren't that stiff. I liked that little legs bend before the impact - Really nice touch. Otherwise, I think that your ani was a bit choppy. and sometimes there was lighting changes (?). Stills very good - nice to see you animating again I vote for Scott for N.3[/b]. His animation was pretty nice as well. It was smooth, it was kinda realistic, it flows well, but I think that it has two flaws: 1) Strings. You didn't edit strings (as usual ^^) and this (as usual) ruined your work, so next time freaking edit them or use black ones (to fit with your BG so you won't have to hide them with a software). 2) Samoa Joe didn't went that high for the Drop and this point that really ruined your efforts. You should've lift him a bit in the air (in like 5 pics?) and it would've be done. Nice reaction, still can be worked on. It was a slightly stiff, and a bit slow as well. However, you did a rigid work. Nicely done I vote for Wes to be N.4. His was probably one of my least liked between all the five animations, but it was very nice. It wasn't really stiff, but a bit choppy, and you should've edited strings. Also, it looks a bit slow so next time, try to speed your anis up. It had a nice and realistic build-up but the hole thing was ruined by stiffness. Stills a great try tough I vote for Fave to be N.5. Well Fave, I gave the fifth spot because your animation didn't even seem like a Muscle Buster to me. It was more like, a botched suplex? However, it was very choppy in mid-air and it was pretty stiff in some parts. I didn't see shadows or strings tough and it had a great rope bounce. Nice BG and camera angle. Sorry for the poopty vote :x | Good luck guys.
|
|
Zack
Main Eventer
Zack isnt my real name :P How many backflips and frontflips did Paul London do? ;D
Joined on: Nov 7, 2010 23:42:23 GMT -5
Posts: 1,164
|
Post by Zack on Mar 2, 2012 6:32:00 GMT -5
Great match guys.
#1- LKS Great Job, nice taunt in the starting, great lift up and great impact. Great reaction and rope bounce too. But Jericho is quite stiff when CM Punk was lifting him and I see a little string. Not much flaw, great job. 9/10
#2-Myyqee Great Job Myyqee, the walking is a nice touch and so is the jump before the move. Not really stiff and nice impact. Also when Dolph is landing, it was a little fidgety. Not much flaw but the lighting changed quite a bit. Nice reaction to the move too. 8.5/10
#3-Fave Great Job Fave, but I can see you didnt really put much effort in it. You should have made a lift up but oh well, very smooth, not stiff and quite realistic. The reaction is poop but the impact in this move is great. Nice rope bounce too. 7.5/10
#4-Scotty Great Job Scotty, but just like Fave, you didnt really put effort in this animation. I can tell because you didnt edit strings and the lift is pretty choppy. it was also very stiff and the reaction isnt that good. But it was smooth and had great impact. Great job on the rope bounce too. 6/10
#5-Wes Great Job Wes, not your best tho. I like how you added a punch but during it, Cm Punk wasnt moving, which made the first part of the animation stiff already. The lift up was a little more faster than the punch and it was very stiff. Not to mention that I see a lot of strings too. But the little running is a nice touch. Reaction and impact isnt really good too. 5/10
Great Match to start the survival of the fittest guys!
|
|
|
Post by wwextreme25 on Mar 2, 2012 10:31:06 GMT -5
#5 wes
the whole animation was lacing pics as it looked somewhat choppy and fidgety, I think you shouldve used a ring like the original but ahh well. well done on having him lie down instead of already being seated,so kudos for doing that but i think it was a bit stiff also. Good effort just, needed more pics and moving of joints. 6.5/10
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#4 scott
Nice work...started off very smooth however, when he actually leant back to do the move, it look stiff and it looked as though there were some pics missing. I think that you shouldve taken more pics as both men fell down as the transition from standing to air was choppy. You TRIED to bend the joints but it didnt really show off as you put your ani together so try making the joint movement more noticable. good job tho it looked nice imo 7/10
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#3 fave
nicely done fave...very smooth and flowed really well. Here is my problem. - it wasnt a muscle buster - more like a brain buster...i think you needed tyson to lean more forward so his shoulder blades hit the canvas not his head...the movement in mid air was a bit strange as they both like, moved air position but great impact an overall flow...had you done the right stip, you may have had a great chance of winning. 7.8/10
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#2 lks
the reason you're 2nd and not 1st (imo) is because i think..the beginning camera angle was cool, but as punk lifted (jericho?) off the ropes, there was like,1/2 pics missing making the transition look choppy. mid air was nice and flowed well - great joint movement but i also think that th impact wasnt as good as it couldve been. By that i mean, you shouldve had jericho land more on the top of his back with his body fully bent...you did a modified suplex? as you had jericho land flat on his back,almost. reaction was cool but yeah...8.2/10
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#1 myyqee
IMO this was really nicely animated. Theonly bad thing i have is WHERE DA FOOOK IS YOUR MEXICANO RING? WITHOUT THAT YOU LOOK...BRITISH (dare i say) :x joking aside, another slight bother was the flashing blue light in the corner. ONTO the animation, i think the animation was superb. Love the lift off from the top rope, nice and smooth - overall great smooth flow of the whole ani. You shouldve have had him lifted from the seating position though, not already in the air. I smell lazyness ;D The camera was a little bit wobbly buti loved zigglers movement in mid air...not stiff at all -great bending of the joints. Perfect speed and tbh yours was the one who's looked most realistic to me so for that, you are my #1 in this match. 8.5/10
|
|
|
Post by [The Ukrainian One] Dimburuk on Mar 2, 2012 10:50:05 GMT -5
1.LKS His was smooth, not stiff, i didn't see shadows or string, loving the reaction, overall it had a nice flow, and looked realistic. Amazing job 2.Myyqee You didn't include lift up, but oh well, it was still very smooth, only a lil lil stiff, liked the reaction, but flash was kinda annoying. 3.Fave I liked it, it was smooth, a bit stiff, i liked the flow of it, but it needs a better reaction. no strings or shadows. it didn't look like a correct move, but still if it counts by host it's okay. 4.Scotty I liked how you tried to make a real replica of animation, but i saw string, lots of string, it was really distracting, also the move flowed well, but it was a bit stiff and choppy. As other people said before, looks like you put no effort. 5. Wes .. wtf Wes? It's not your best, it was very choppy, bad string editing, stiff, needs a better reaction.. Looks a bit slow because the amount of frames is low.
|
|
Deleted
Joined on: Apr 18, 2024 4:55:48 GMT -5
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Mar 2, 2012 16:23:02 GMT -5
#1 Scott Yours was the only one who had an animation that actually looked like a muscle busterbut dude work on getting the string out I use gimp its a free program 8.5 out of 10 #2 LKS really smooth but the pick up was choppy and also I thought Jericho could of been more bent if you know what I mean 8.4 out of 10 #3 Fave really good but just a little floaty on the spin but this is really good 8.3 out of 10 #4McQue Not sure how your going to pull it at Animania that wasnt good choppy the camera moved to much saw wire needed more pics and also looked likeyou sometimes had flash on and off overall 5 out of 10 #5 Wes pathetic when I saw it I thought I misread the stip looks like a suplex also saw wire and it was slow missing some pics choppy and saw where your arm or hand was at in a few pics overall 3.5 out of 10
Really wish I was in this match LOL
|
|
|
Post by Scotty on Mar 2, 2012 17:09:27 GMT -5
tbh i think we should just keep this match instead of having 2 matches
|
|
|
Post by /X Metal Sorenges x "Mac Oh J~ on Mar 2, 2012 18:47:27 GMT -5
#2 LKS: The set up was nice, The lift into the muscle buster looked good. The movements back when it took Jericho off the ropes looked a bit to fast and the follow up movements afterwards were to fast aswell. The Muscle Buster didn't look much like one, the angle of the slam was or in light of a suplex rather then a Muscle Buster and the way CM Punk legs were positioned in mid air looked a bit off. Chris Jericho reaction was a bit spastic but it was overall not that bad.
#5 Wes: The set up was ok, the punch at the beginning was smooth but CM Punk was really stiff after the impact. The lift was smooth but a bit fast, the running to add impact to the move was a great touch, there was much impact but CM Punk didn't have a reaction.
#3 Fave: Could have started the beginning with a little bit of build up but still not bad for the effort you put into what you made regardless. I like the bend before the Muscle Buster itself, the turn into the muscle buster lacked impact, realism and compaction in the move. The rope bounce was nice though
#1 Myyqee: The set up was good, the walking while Ryder was in the air was nicely done. The running jump looked perfect along with the position of how to Muscle Buster was almost flawless. Dolph looked a bit blurry after the impact but Chavo's reaction looked great.
#4 Scott: The set up was good, I like the lift from the turnbuckle onto Joe's shoulders. The walking flowed well but the Muscle Buster lacked impact and high during the jump which made it look a bit unrealistic. I do like Jack's reaction though.
|
|