WF Day Of Reckoning: Dark Match 2

Mitch:
Cool animation. I like everything about it, but what REALLY subtracts from it is the shakiness. The entire animation is shaky. I like that you added the pin though.

Andeh:
Great animation, flowed great and I liked everything about it, camera was kept very still.

VOTE: ANDEH

my vote goes the ANDEH!

they were both pretty smooth but andy's was more smooth. mitch's ani went a little too slow and it looks slightly choppy, mitch's camera was shaky pretty much the whole time while andy's was perfectly still. i saw lots of shadows in adehs and the reaction wasnt as good but overall the animation was better. it was a close match but my vote goes to ANDEH!

Gonna go with andeh, something about it seemed more realistic, I think it was the speed, and the use of Elite/Deluxe articulation, Mitch's look alot stiffer compared to that.

Vote ANDEH
Reason-
Mitch's ziz zag was o.k the speed really lets it down, the speed was slow and the animation was stiff.
Vote Andeh!

I vote Andeh.
In my opinion his was better then Mitch's. Andehs was smooth and flowed well. Mitch's was smooth but it was shaky.

Vote: Andeh

MiTCH: I thought it was pretty smooth, Johnny Nitro was a tiny stiff in the animation, also it was a tiny shaky at times, but that is nothing. There was no blurriness in the animation, the lighting was great, saw tiny bits of string, but did not see any shadows or hands, not fidgety or floaty at all during the animation, liked the punches in the beginning, also liked how you showed Shelton win in the end, the impact needs a tiny bit more work, and the reaction does too.
OVERALL: 7/10

Andeh-N.E.W: Liked the uppercut in the beginning, it was smooth as usual, it was not stiff at all during the animation, the lighting was good, not shaky at all, not blurry either, saw no string or shadows, but did see some shadows in the animation, not fidgety or floaty at all, the reaction needs somemore work but the impact was great.
OVERALL: 8/10

VOTE: Andeh-N.E.W

My vote goes to ANDEH!

Andeh: Yours was smooth, I liked the uppercut thing at the beginning and the zig zag was smooth. Reactions were good and I liked the animation. I thought it looked very realistic aswell.

Mitch: Yours was good and smooth, the punches at the beginning were a nice effect. The zig zag itself was good and so was the fall in it the only thing that made me not vote for you, was it was a little slow, and it looked shakey at the end of the zig zag and during the reation.

Andeh: 9/10
Mitch: 8/10

Vote Andeh


Reason: Super smooth, very realistic and not stiiff or choppy. I didnt vote for Mitch because his was a bit slow, stiff and slightly choppy.